There is 1 comment.
 
 
Confluence / cid:jira-generated-image-avatar-e72581c0-b3d3-4105-924c-0200955aa1c5 CONFLUENCE-133 Open

Solved inline comments get imported and displayed into XWiki

 
View issue   ยท   Add comment
 

1 comment

 
cid:jira-generated-image-avatar-96bb63c9-015d-4caa-9301-599b2885e438 Anca Luca on 15/Sep/24 12:28
 

the behavior you describe is exactly what happen for an XWiki annotation which used to match a content that was modified (i.e. a resolved annotation)

Not really. For annotations of XWiki, the altered state is a state set automatically when an annotation is automatically repositioned when the content is modified. A user "resolving" that annotation confirms that the annotation is still valid in the new content, as it was modified, to show it again as a "regular" annotation.
The resolving of inline comments in Confluence has the opposite purpose: to mark that they're not relevant anymore and should not be displayed: this is done for various reasons, but mostly bearing the meaning that the suggestion from that inline comment / annotation was handled. It would be indeed equivalent to deleting the annotation in XWiki, but I don't think we should just skip the import of all resolved inline comments. We could add an option in the importer to skip resolved comments or not.