[xwiki-devs] [xwiki-dev] [Proposal] Document comments should not create new versions
vincent at massol.net
Mon Sep 10 07:39:59 UTC 2007
(resending - I sent it on the 6th to the wrong OW dev list...)
> If we don't increase version then how is it going to appear in the
> history view. Namely, how would you see that a comment has been added?
> Of course we would still need to send notifications even when
> comments are added.
> This is a general question about objects attached to a document. As
> of now I'm not sure we should treat some objects differently than
> Just to step back and play the devil, why is it bad that document
> version is increased when comments are added?
> On Aug 24, 2007, at 4:44 PM, Sergiu Dumitriu wrote:
>> This is more a matter of opinions. Should a comment increase the
>> version of a document? I'd say yes, but the view of simple users is
>> that a comment should not affect the document, as it is something
>> describing the document, not belonging to the document. So we should
>> have a parameter that configures this.
More information about the devs