Allow 'Edit Macro' dialog to be opened by default when a macro that needs configuration is inserted through Quick Actions

Anca Luca Thanks for sharing your searches!

> My understanding is that this issue may occur only for some macros, more specifically for the ones for which the mandatory parameters cannot be marked as such because it's a group of parameters of which one is mandatory but no single one is mandatory, is this correct, Charpentier Lucas (and/or Ilie Andriuta) ?

Yup, that's also what I understand from this situation.

> In this case, isn't this a duplicate of XWIKI-20945 ?

XWIKI-20945 and XWIKI-20944 are both very close to what's described here, but they talk about specific macros. IMO if we provide a proper generic fix for this ticket, XWIKI-20945 and XWIKI-20944 should be `Solved By` it and closed

> Or, if this is for the generic possibility to mark a group of parameters as mandatory, it's the same as XWIKI-23043 ?

AFAIU, this possibility to mark a group of parameters as mandatory is implemented ( XCOMMONS-2738 ) and already somewhat useful since Simon Urli implemented validation based on it for XWIKI-23043.
But validation is not the only thing we want to do with these new marks, one thing is to (like "standard" mandatory fields) to open the edition dialog when creating a macro that contains at least one field with a "mandatory feature" mark. Having the mandatory feature mark influence the creation UX as expected would fix the problem described in this ticket.
Note that back in March I assumed I'd have to implement what was done in XWIKI-23043 just so that this feature would make sense

___
Sidenote: I did forget about this ticket for a few releases, unassigning myself. If we don't need to solve it quickly, I'll try to handle it into the September roadmap.