There are 4 comments.
 
 
XWiki Platform / cid:jira-generated-image-avatar-02041570-1caf-4213-a5c1-c730402b298f XWIKI-22583 Open

Allow users with edit rights on a page and all its children to use the Pinned Pages feature

 
View issue   ยท   Add comment
 

4 comments

 
cid:jira-generated-image-avatar-745b8b8f-02af-400f-8559-d970e920c6cf Anca Luca on 17/Oct/24 18:20
 

Actually, it can be argued that this is not an improvement but I bug.

I understand that from the point of view of the way the pinned pages (tree order) are stored the current behavior is the most "natural" one, but from a content creation point of view, for a user that is writing content, not being able to order their subpages without calling an admin for help feels like a bug more than anything...

 
cid:jira-generated-image-avatar-745b8b8f-02af-400f-8559-d970e920c6cf Anca Luca on 17/Oct/24 18:21
 
Actually, it can be argued that this is not an improvement but I bug.

I understand that from the point of view of the way the pinned pages (tree order) are stored the current behavior is the most "natural" one, but from a content creation point of view, for a user that is writing content, not being able to order their subpages without calling an admin for help feels like a bug more than anything
- makes the order feature usable in very, very little situations, in practice . ..
 
cid:jira-generated-image-avatar-745b8b8f-02af-400f-8559-d970e920c6cf Anca Luca on 17/Oct/24 18:27
 

From a logical point of view, this action is "tied" ("related") with the move, copy or create action: these are the actions where page tree placement is chosen today, and the order is part of this placement. Which brings us to the edit right on a tree of pages (page and children).

 
cid:jira-generated-image-avatar-745b8b8f-02af-400f-8559-d970e920c6cf Anca Luca on 17/Oct/24 18:29
 
Actually, it can be argued that this is not an improvement but I a bug.

I understand that from the point of view of the way the pinned pages (tree order) are stored the current behavior is the most "natural" one, but from a content creation point of view, for a user that is writing content, not being able to order their subpages without calling an admin for help feels like a bug more than anything - makes the order feature usable in very, very little situations, in practice.