Hi! I never got an answer to this email. Did I miss a point in some way? Were my comments not what you guys actually asked for? Maybe I should add the suggestions and the screenshots to the jira issue XWIKI-523? Anyway, I'll be offline for a month now, so I won't have the chance to follow up on the discussion. I hope all you devoted developers also get the break you want or deserve this summer; you're doing an impressive job on xwiki! best regards :-) Thomas -------- Original Message -------- Subject: Re: [xwiki-dev] Regarding issue XWIKI-523 (Tags should be shown with comments and attachments) Date: Mon, 11 Jun 2007 11:45:28 +0200 From: Thomas Drevon <[email protected]> Reply-To: [email protected] To: [email protected] References: <[email protected]> <[email protected]> Vincent Massol wrote:

Here's how we could work together: you send some emails on the list, maybe with some GUI mockups about how you think tags should be integrated. You'll get lots of feedbacks I'm sure, especially if you show something in a mockup (people love images ;-)). Then you start sending some emails about how you think it should be done and committers will comment, tell you if there's a better way. And you can ask for any question you have along the way.

WDYT?

Sure! Ok here we go: 1. View tags along with a document. It doesn't really matter what kind of document, but for this example I've used a blog entry. See the attached file called blog_entry_view.png. In order to achieve this, just add the following lines to an appropriate place in XWiki.ArticleClassSheet: <code> Tags: #foreach($tag in $doc.getTagList()) <a href="$xwiki.getURL("Main.Tags", "view", "tag=$tag")")">$tag</a> #end </code> This code is tested and works fine. Problem: On docs without a template sheet, this gets a bit more messy, as it seems the above code must be added directly to content.vm. Maybe all docs should inherit from some sort of generic template sheet? This will give users more flexibility by sparing them the messing up of velocity files, and thus making an upgrade of their xwiki version harder. And by the way, is it correct that while viewing this doc, the breadcrumbs read "BLOG: Administration > Samarkand" even though I'm not logged in? "Administration" here seems a bit strange? 2. Intuitive edit of tags while in edit mode. See the attached file called blog_entry_edit.png. In order to achieve this, add the following lines to the correct place in XWiki.ArticleClassSheet: <code> <dt>Tags:</dt> <dd><input type="text" id="tags" name="tags" size="60" value="$!tdoc.tags"/></dd> </code> Though this code produces a nice input field as expected, tags entered here will not be saved along with the doc, unless the servlet engine is restarted between the creation of the docs and the editing of tags. Strange. Well, what do you think? Oh yes, and I'm all for letting users turn on/off the tag functionality in xwiki.cfg, by the way. cheers :-) Thomas