1.0 Beta 6 & 1.0 Status as of 26 March 2007
Hi, The 1.0 Beta 6 release is supposed to be delivered today but that's going to be hard. There are still 51 issues open for it... I think we really need to release the rename feature with the UI for B6 and I would suggest we postpone it by a few days to include this. Sergiu can you let us know when you'll have the UI finished? On my side, I've discovered a few issues with the backend implementation that I'll fix today and tomorrow. Would it be possible to release B6 on Wednesday? This also means that we'll never be able to fix the 51 issues for Wednesday. I've done a sorting of the opened issues scheduled for 1.0 (B6 included): Important ======== - Rename issues (21, 1022, 1014, 935) - 1011 - WYSIWYG (954, 775, 418) - 726 ?? - 651 - 464 - 216 (?) - 138 (?) Less important ============ - 1005 - 1000 - 965, 947, 757, 517 (Lucene plugin issues) - 936 - 934 - 932 - 872 - 860 - 786 - 754 - 729 - 704 - 695 (?) - 665 - 646 (?) - 615 - 605 - 593 - 592 - 590 - 589 - 587 (almost done) - 524 - 448 - 432 - 351 (?) - PDF: 257, 237, 185 - 181 - 114 - 110 - 56 - 55 Documentation ============ - 982 - 1009 - 770 - 771 - 772 - 720 - 721 - 722 - 717 - 718 - 627 - 586 The question marks means I'm not sure about the severity of the issue. Note that this sorting is done based on how critical it is to XWiki Core and for 1.0. It's not based on any issue requirements for a specific project using XWiki, etc. It means that IMO this is what we need to fix at the minimum to release XWiki 1.0. Please also note that we need to do a pass of the other opened issues that do not have a "fix for" set in JIRA (there are 187 of them). I'll try to do this later today. Thus if we look at the issues above, we see that there are "only" 13 "important" ones for 1.0. We can probably kill 7 till Wednesday, which means it'll remain 6 issues for RC1 (+ possibly the other very important ones we'll find by reviewing the issues that have no "fix for" yet). Thus I think that after we release B6 (possibly on Wednesday) we should move the remaining issues in RC1 and not do a new B7. Once we start RC we shouldn't put any new feature but rather commit any new features on the trunk only. WDYT? Thanks -Vincent
Vincent Massol wrote: <SNIP>
Thus I think that after we release B6 (possibly on Wednesday) we should move the remaining issues in RC1 and not do a new B7. Once we start RC we shouldn't put any new feature but rather commit any new features on the trunk only.
WDYT?
I'm using OSS regularly and I was even a member of some projects and what I found out is that most of the time people are not sure when to declare 1.0. Net is plagued with OSS project sticking to 0.9.x versions for years. There is a lot of reason to do that: * you are doing this for yourself, therefore it must be perfect * you want to freeze external interfaces for good * you are not sure what should be in version 1.0 Due to the dynamic nature of the software it is not really possible to satisfy all this criteria. Software is changing all the time. That's why we got agile methods and refactoring. Reluctance to declare 1.0 turns away users because they think software is not good until 1.0, and most of these projects are. So, forget about dates, but rather decide what features should be present in 1.0, cut the rest, fix major bugs and release it. I think you are on the good track.
Hello everybody, When I look at my "catalina.out" file, I've got plenty of warnings like that: 15:32:09,797 WARN http-8080-Processor25 http://132.169.8.223:8080/xwiki/bin/view/Main/ MonitorData:log:183 - MONITOR Main.WebHome: 454ms 15:32:10,562 WARN http-8080-Processor25 http://132.169.8.223:8080/xwiki/bin/download/Main/WebHome/euromap MonitorData:log:183 - MONITOR Main.WebHome: 47ms 15:32:25,515 WARN http-8080-Processor23 http://132.169.8.223:8080/xwiki/bin/edit/Main/WebHome?&editor=wiki MonitorData:log:183 - MONITOR Main.WebHome: 234ms 15:32:26,281 WARN http-8080-Processor25 http://132.169.8.223:8080/xwiki/bin/lock/Main/WebHome?ajax=1& MonitorData:log:183 - MONITOR Main.WebHome: 16ms 15:32:48,328 WARN http-8080-Processor22 http://132.169.8.223:8080/xwiki/bin/save/Main/WebHome MonitorData:log:183 - MONITOR Main.WebHome: 203ms Is it normal ? Thanks, Mathieu --------------------------------------------------- Mathieu Emptoz CEA Cadarache DRFC/STEP XWiki's EFDA Remote Participation Administrator ---------------------------------------------------
Hi Mathieu, On Mar 28, 2007, at 3:40 PM, EMPTOZ Mathieu 310507 wrote:
Hello everybody,
When I look at my "catalina.out" file, I've got plenty of warnings like that:
15:32:09,797 WARN http-8080-Processor25 http://132.169.8.223:8080/xwiki/bin/view/Main/ MonitorData:log:183 - MONITOR Main.WebHome: 454ms 15:32:10,562 WARN http-8080-Processor25 http://132.169.8.223:8080/xwiki/bin/download/Main/WebHome/euromap MonitorData:log:183 - MONITOR Main.WebHome: 47ms 15:32:25,515 WARN http-8080-Processor23 http://132.169.8.223:8080/xwiki/bin/edit/Main/WebHome?&editor=wiki MonitorData:log:183 - MONITOR Main.WebHome: 234ms 15:32:26,281 WARN http-8080-Processor25 http://132.169.8.223:8080/xwiki/bin/lock/Main/WebHome?ajax=1& MonitorData:log:183 - MONITOR Main.WebHome: 16ms 15:32:48,328 WARN http-8080-Processor22 http://132.169.8.223:8080/xwiki/bin/save/Main/WebHome MonitorData:log:183 - MONITOR Main.WebHome: 203ms
Is it normal ?
See http://jira.xwiki.org/jira/browse/XWIKI-1003 Thanks -Vincent
participants (3)
-
EMPTOZ Mathieu 310507 -
Vincent Massol -
Zeljko Trogrlic