[xwiki-devs] [VOTE] Move XWiki GWT modules from web to platform
Hi devs, I'd like to suggest to move our current xwiki-web-gwt and xwiki-web-wysiwyg modules from platform/web to platform/. Rationale : - Generic GWT modules to come (wiki-explorer, color picker, etc). - xwiki-web would hold only fully functional WARs. - WYSIWYG release cycle should be different from the one of web. This would allow to benefit from WYSIWYG improvements in branch releases (ex: XE 1.7.2, 1.7.3, etc) without requiring devs to commit on multiple branches. - A lot of issues regarding the wysiwyg editor are created in the XWiki Core project in jira, I think having a dedicated project makes sense. Current organization : |- platform/ |- web/ (xwiki-web) |- exo/ (xwiki-web-exo) |- gwt/ (xwiki-web-gwt) |- standard/ (xwiki-web-standard) |- wysiwyg/ (xwiki-web-wysiwyg) New organization proposal : |- platform/ |- gwt/ (xwiki-gwt) |- commons/ (xwiki-gwt-commons) |- wysiwyg/ (xwiki--gwt-wysiwyg) |- web/ (xwiki-web) |- exo/ (xwiki-web-exo) |- standard/ (xwiki-web-standard) This would also mean that we'd need 2 new projects in JIRA : XWiki GWT Commons (XGCOMMONS) and XWiki GWT WYSIWYG (XGWYSIWYG). Here's my +1. Thanks, JV.
+1 Jean-Vincent Drean wrote:
Hi devs,
I'd like to suggest to move our current xwiki-web-gwt and xwiki-web-wysiwyg modules from platform/web to platform/.
Rationale : - Generic GWT modules to come (wiki-explorer, color picker, etc). - xwiki-web would hold only fully functional WARs. - WYSIWYG release cycle should be different from the one of web. This would allow to benefit from WYSIWYG improvements in branch releases (ex: XE 1.7.2, 1.7.3, etc) without requiring devs to commit on multiple branches. - A lot of issues regarding the wysiwyg editor are created in the XWiki Core project in jira, I think having a dedicated project makes sense.
Current organization : |- platform/ |- web/ (xwiki-web) |- exo/ (xwiki-web-exo) |- gwt/ (xwiki-web-gwt) |- standard/ (xwiki-web-standard) |- wysiwyg/ (xwiki-web-wysiwyg)
New organization proposal : |- platform/ |- gwt/ (xwiki-gwt) |- commons/ (xwiki-gwt-commons) |- wysiwyg/ (xwiki--gwt-wysiwyg) |- web/ (xwiki-web) |- exo/ (xwiki-web-exo) |- standard/ (xwiki-web-standard)
This would also mean that we'd need 2 new projects in JIRA : XWiki GWT Commons (XGCOMMONS) and XWiki GWT WYSIWYG (XGWYSIWYG).
Here's my +1.
Thanks, JV. _______________________________________________ devs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
Big +1 Jean-Vincent Drean wrote:
Hi devs,
I'd like to suggest to move our current xwiki-web-gwt and xwiki-web-wysiwyg modules from platform/web to platform/.
Rationale : - Generic GWT modules to come (wiki-explorer, color picker, etc). - xwiki-web would hold only fully functional WARs. - WYSIWYG release cycle should be different from the one of web. This would allow to benefit from WYSIWYG improvements in branch releases (ex: XE 1.7.2, 1.7.3, etc) without requiring devs to commit on multiple branches. - A lot of issues regarding the wysiwyg editor are created in the XWiki Core project in jira, I think having a dedicated project makes sense.
Current organization : |- platform/ |- web/ (xwiki-web) |- exo/ (xwiki-web-exo) |- gwt/ (xwiki-web-gwt) |- standard/ (xwiki-web-standard) |- wysiwyg/ (xwiki-web-wysiwyg)
New organization proposal : |- platform/ |- gwt/ (xwiki-gwt) |- commons/ (xwiki-gwt-commons) |- wysiwyg/ (xwiki--gwt-wysiwyg) |- web/ (xwiki-web) |- exo/ (xwiki-web-exo) |- standard/ (xwiki-web-standard)
This would also mean that we'd need 2 new projects in JIRA : XWiki GWT Commons (XGCOMMONS) and XWiki GWT WYSIWYG (XGWYSIWYG).
Here's my +1.
Thanks, JV. _______________________________________________ devs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
+1, looking forward great commons. Jerome Jean-Vincent Drean wrote:
Hi devs,
I'd like to suggest to move our current xwiki-web-gwt and xwiki-web-wysiwyg modules from platform/web to platform/.
Rationale : - Generic GWT modules to come (wiki-explorer, color picker, etc). - xwiki-web would hold only fully functional WARs. - WYSIWYG release cycle should be different from the one of web. This would allow to benefit from WYSIWYG improvements in branch releases (ex: XE 1.7.2, 1.7.3, etc) without requiring devs to commit on multiple branches. - A lot of issues regarding the wysiwyg editor are created in the XWiki Core project in jira, I think having a dedicated project makes sense.
Current organization : |- platform/ |- web/ (xwiki-web) |- exo/ (xwiki-web-exo) |- gwt/ (xwiki-web-gwt) |- standard/ (xwiki-web-standard) |- wysiwyg/ (xwiki-web-wysiwyg)
New organization proposal : |- platform/ |- gwt/ (xwiki-gwt) |- commons/ (xwiki-gwt-commons) |- wysiwyg/ (xwiki--gwt-wysiwyg) |- web/ (xwiki-web) |- exo/ (xwiki-web-exo) |- standard/ (xwiki-web-standard)
This would also mean that we'd need 2 new projects in JIRA : XWiki GWT Commons (XGCOMMONS) and XWiki GWT WYSIWYG (XGWYSIWYG).
Here's my +1.
Thanks, JV. _______________________________________________ devs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
+1 Also it would be better to have all WYSIWYF project pure java (the one not converted into javascript) in a jar project on which the the WYSIWYG war project depends. On Thu, Dec 11, 2008 at 3:50 PM, Jean-Vincent Drean <[email protected]> wrote:
Hi devs,
I'd like to suggest to move our current xwiki-web-gwt and xwiki-web-wysiwyg modules from platform/web to platform/.
Rationale : - Generic GWT modules to come (wiki-explorer, color picker, etc). - xwiki-web would hold only fully functional WARs. - WYSIWYG release cycle should be different from the one of web. This would allow to benefit from WYSIWYG improvements in branch releases (ex: XE 1.7.2, 1.7.3, etc) without requiring devs to commit on multiple branches. - A lot of issues regarding the wysiwyg editor are created in the XWiki Core project in jira, I think having a dedicated project makes sense.
Current organization : |- platform/ |- web/ (xwiki-web) |- exo/ (xwiki-web-exo) |- gwt/ (xwiki-web-gwt) |- standard/ (xwiki-web-standard) |- wysiwyg/ (xwiki-web-wysiwyg)
New organization proposal : |- platform/ |- gwt/ (xwiki-gwt) |- commons/ (xwiki-gwt-commons) |- wysiwyg/ (xwiki--gwt-wysiwyg) |- web/ (xwiki-web) |- exo/ (xwiki-web-exo) |- standard/ (xwiki-web-standard)
This would also mean that we'd need 2 new projects in JIRA : XWiki GWT Commons (XGCOMMONS) and XWiki GWT WYSIWYG (XGWYSIWYG).
Here's my +1.
Thanks, JV. _______________________________________________ devs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
-- Thomas Mortagne
participants (5)
-
Anca Paula Luca -
Jean-Vincent Drean -
Jerome Velociter -
Marius Dumitru Florea -
Thomas Mortagne