[xwiki-devs] JAR Duplicates in 4.3 Milestone 1 and SNAPSHOT
Hello everybody, After the release of 4.3 Milestone 1, I wanted to start testing the new features but I ran into an issue ( http://jira.xwiki.org/browse/XWIKI-8365 ) when starting and accessing the Wiki based on 4.3 M1. After Marius helped me figure out the cause, it seemed that we had a jar duplication of Xalan in our Manager package. I have tested this on another machine and wasn't able to reproduce. Fabio also tested, without success, but the duplication is clear - I had 2 Xalan jars in my /lib folder (even on the machine where I had no errors). After that, I started to look for other duplicates in my /lib folder. Below are my findings. Checked these 2 XWiki packages to be sure it's not package dependant: * xwiki-manager-jetty-hsqldb * xwiki-manager-jetty-mysql Found the following JAR duplicates: 1) activation-1.1.1.jar activation-1.1.jar 2) commons-lang3-3.1.1jar commons-lang-2.6.jar 3) jdom-1.0 jdom-1.1.jar 4) plexus-utils-2.0.6.jar plexus-utils-2.0.7.jar 5) rome-0.9.jar rome-1.0.0.jar rome 1.0.jar 6) vorbis-java-core-0.1.jar vorbis-java-core-0.1-tests.jar 7) xercesImpl-2.9.1.jar xercesImpl-2.8.1.jar After the release of 4.3 M1 I have also downloaded a 4.3-SNAPSHOT build (xwiki-manager-jetty-hsqldb-4.3-20121025.181227-95.zip). Besides the duplicates from above, I have also found a lot of XWiki jars duplicated. Note, the list if far from being complete ! xwiki-commons-classloader-api-4.3-20121024.173322-34.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-protocol-jar-4.3-20121024.173330-34.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-protocol-jar-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-component-observation-4.3-20121024.173347-34.jar xwiki-commons-component-observation-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-configuration-api-4.3-20121024.173413-34.jar xwiki-commons-configuration-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-context-4.3-20121024.173359-34.jar xwiki-commons-context-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-diff-api-4.3-20121024.173722-33.jar xwiki-commons-diff-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-platform-bridge-4.3-20121025.165136-181.jar xwiki-platform-bridge-4.3-20121025.174305-182.jar xwiki-platform-cache-api-4.3-20121025.165403-177.jar xwiki-platform-cache-api-4.3-20121025.174540-178.jar xwiki-platform-cache-infinispan-4.3-20121025.165428-177.jar xwiki-platform-cache-infinispan-4.3-20121025.174606-178.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-icon-4.3-20121024.193826-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-icon-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-linkchecker-4.3-20121024.193846-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-macro-4.3-20121024.193051-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-macro-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-wikiword-4.3-20121024.193833-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-wikiword-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar Items statistics: /lib folder on SNAPSHOT : 126.6 MB - 445 Items /lib folder on Milestone 1: 126.3 MB - 392 Items The odd thing is that I do not get any warnings, errors, stacktraces when starting the 4.3-SNAPSHOT. I wrote this mail to report the issue, because IMO this can cause serious issues. Regards, Sorin B.
On Fri, Oct 26, 2012 at 4:21 PM, Sorin Burjan <[email protected]> wrote:
Hello everybody,
After the release of 4.3 Milestone 1, I wanted to start testing the new features but I ran into an issue ( http://jira.xwiki.org/browse/XWIKI-8365 ) when starting and accessing the Wiki based on 4.3 M1. After Marius helped me figure out the cause, it seemed that we had a jar duplication of Xalan in our Manager package. I have tested this on another machine and wasn't able to reproduce. Fabio also tested, without success, but the duplication is clear - I had 2 Xalan jars in my /lib folder (even on the machine where I had no errors).
After that, I started to look for other duplicates in my /lib folder. Below are my findings. Checked these 2 XWiki packages to be sure it's not package dependant: * xwiki-manager-jetty-hsqldb * xwiki-manager-jetty-mysql
Found the following JAR duplicates:
1) activation-1.1.1.jar activation-1.1.jar
2) commons-lang3-3.1.1jar commons-lang-2.6.jar
This is not a duplicate.
3) jdom-1.0 jdom-1.1.jar
4) plexus-utils-2.0.6.jar plexus-utils-2.0.7.jar
5) rome-0.9.jar rome-1.0.0.jar rome 1.0.jar
6) vorbis-java-core-0.1.jar vorbis-java-core-0.1-tests.jar
7) xercesImpl-2.9.1.jar xercesImpl-2.8.1.jar
After the release of 4.3 M1 I have also downloaded a 4.3-SNAPSHOT build (xwiki-manager-jetty-hsqldb-4.3-20121025.181227-95.zip). Besides the duplicates from above, I have also found a lot of XWiki jars duplicated. Note, the list if far from being complete !
xwiki-commons-classloader-api-4.3-20121024.173322-34.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-protocol-jar-4.3-20121024.173330-34.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-protocol-jar-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-component-observation-4.3-20121024.173347-34.jar xwiki-commons-component-observation-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-configuration-api-4.3-20121024.173413-34.jar xwiki-commons-configuration-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-context-4.3-20121024.173359-34.jar xwiki-commons-context-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-diff-api-4.3-20121024.173722-33.jar xwiki-commons-diff-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-platform-bridge-4.3-20121025.165136-181.jar xwiki-platform-bridge-4.3-20121025.174305-182.jar xwiki-platform-cache-api-4.3-20121025.165403-177.jar xwiki-platform-cache-api-4.3-20121025.174540-178.jar xwiki-platform-cache-infinispan-4.3-20121025.165428-177.jar xwiki-platform-cache-infinispan-4.3-20121025.174606-178.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-icon-4.3-20121024.193826-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-icon-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-linkchecker-4.3-20121024.193846-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-macro-4.3-20121024.193051-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-macro-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-wikiword-4.3-20121024.193833-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-wikiword-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar
Thoses are perfectly normal and happen only in SNAPSHOT.
Items statistics: /lib folder on SNAPSHOT : 126.6 MB - 445 Items /lib folder on Milestone 1: 126.3 MB - 392 Items
The odd thing is that I do not get any warnings, errors, stacktraces when starting the 4.3-SNAPSHOT. I wrote this mail to report the issue, because IMO this can cause serious issues.
Regards, Sorin B. _______________________________________________ devs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
-- Thomas Mortagne
On Fri, Oct 26, 2012 at 5:51 PM, Thomas Mortagne <[email protected]> wrote:
On Fri, Oct 26, 2012 at 4:21 PM, Sorin Burjan <[email protected]> wrote:
Hello everybody,
After the release of 4.3 Milestone 1, I wanted to start testing the new features but I ran into an issue ( http://jira.xwiki.org/browse/XWIKI-8365 ) when starting and accessing the Wiki based on 4.3 M1. After Marius helped me figure out the cause, it seemed that we had a jar duplication of Xalan in our Manager package. I have tested this on another machine and wasn't able to reproduce. Fabio also tested, without success, but the duplication is clear - I had 2 Xalan jars in my /lib folder (even on the machine where I had no errors).
After that, I started to look for other duplicates in my /lib folder. Below are my findings. Checked these 2 XWiki packages to be sure it's not package dependant: * xwiki-manager-jetty-hsqldb * xwiki-manager-jetty-mysql
Found the following JAR duplicates:
1) activation-1.1.1.jar activation-1.1.jar
2) commons-lang3-3.1.1jar commons-lang-2.6.jar
This is not a duplicate.
3) jdom-1.0 jdom-1.1.jar
4) plexus-utils-2.0.6.jar plexus-utils-2.0.7.jar
5) rome-0.9.jar rome-1.0.0.jar rome 1.0.jar
6) vorbis-java-core-0.1.jar vorbis-java-core-0.1-tests.jar
7) xercesImpl-2.9.1.jar xercesImpl-2.8.1.jar
After the release of 4.3 M1 I have also downloaded a 4.3-SNAPSHOT build (xwiki-manager-jetty-hsqldb-4.3-20121025.181227-95.zip). Besides the duplicates from above, I have also found a lot of XWiki jars duplicated. Note, the list if far from being complete !
xwiki-commons-classloader-api-4.3-20121024.173322-34.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-protocol-jar-4.3-20121024.173330-34.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-protocol-jar-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-component-observation-4.3-20121024.173347-34.jar xwiki-commons-component-observation-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-configuration-api-4.3-20121024.173413-34.jar xwiki-commons-configuration-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-context-4.3-20121024.173359-34.jar xwiki-commons-context-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-diff-api-4.3-20121024.173722-33.jar xwiki-commons-diff-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-platform-bridge-4.3-20121025.165136-181.jar xwiki-platform-bridge-4.3-20121025.174305-182.jar xwiki-platform-cache-api-4.3-20121025.165403-177.jar xwiki-platform-cache-api-4.3-20121025.174540-178.jar xwiki-platform-cache-infinispan-4.3-20121025.165428-177.jar xwiki-platform-cache-infinispan-4.3-20121025.174606-178.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-icon-4.3-20121024.193826-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-icon-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-linkchecker-4.3-20121024.193846-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-macro-4.3-20121024.193051-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-macro-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-wikiword-4.3-20121024.193833-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-wikiword-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar
Thoses are perfectly normal and happen only in SNAPSHOT.
Are you sure ? I am looking on a 4.2 SNAPSHOT - http://maven.xwiki.org/snapshots/org/xwiki/manager/xwiki-manager-jetty-mysql... and I don't have these kind of duplications. Regards, Sorin B.
Items statistics: /lib folder on SNAPSHOT : 126.6 MB - 445 Items /lib folder on Milestone 1: 126.3 MB - 392 Items
The odd thing is that I do not get any warnings, errors, stacktraces when starting the 4.3-SNAPSHOT. I wrote this mail to report the issue, because IMO this can cause serious issues.
Regards, Sorin B. _______________________________________________ devs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
-- Thomas Mortagne _______________________________________________ devs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
On Fri, Oct 26, 2012 at 6:03 PM, Sorin Burjan <[email protected]> wrote:
On Fri, Oct 26, 2012 at 5:51 PM, Thomas Mortagne <[email protected]> wrote:
On Fri, Oct 26, 2012 at 4:21 PM, Sorin Burjan <[email protected]> wrote:
Hello everybody,
After the release of 4.3 Milestone 1, I wanted to start testing the new features but I ran into an issue ( http://jira.xwiki.org/browse/XWIKI-8365 ) when starting and accessing the Wiki based on 4.3 M1. After Marius helped me figure out the cause, it seemed that we had a jar duplication of Xalan in our Manager package. I have tested this on another machine and wasn't able to reproduce. Fabio also tested, without success, but the duplication is clear - I had 2 Xalan jars in my /lib folder (even on the machine where I had no errors).
After that, I started to look for other duplicates in my /lib folder. Below are my findings. Checked these 2 XWiki packages to be sure it's not package dependant: * xwiki-manager-jetty-hsqldb * xwiki-manager-jetty-mysql
Found the following JAR duplicates:
1) activation-1.1.1.jar activation-1.1.jar
2) commons-lang3-3.1.1jar commons-lang-2.6.jar
This is not a duplicate.
3) jdom-1.0 jdom-1.1.jar
4) plexus-utils-2.0.6.jar plexus-utils-2.0.7.jar
5) rome-0.9.jar rome-1.0.0.jar rome 1.0.jar
6) vorbis-java-core-0.1.jar vorbis-java-core-0.1-tests.jar
7) xercesImpl-2.9.1.jar xercesImpl-2.8.1.jar
After the release of 4.3 M1 I have also downloaded a 4.3-SNAPSHOT build (xwiki-manager-jetty-hsqldb-4.3-20121025.181227-95.zip). Besides the duplicates from above, I have also found a lot of XWiki jars duplicated. Note, the list if far from being complete !
xwiki-commons-classloader-api-4.3-20121024.173322-34.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-protocol-jar-4.3-20121024.173330-34.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-protocol-jar-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-component-observation-4.3-20121024.173347-34.jar xwiki-commons-component-observation-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-configuration-api-4.3-20121024.173413-34.jar xwiki-commons-configuration-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-context-4.3-20121024.173359-34.jar xwiki-commons-context-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-diff-api-4.3-20121024.173722-33.jar xwiki-commons-diff-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-platform-bridge-4.3-20121025.165136-181.jar xwiki-platform-bridge-4.3-20121025.174305-182.jar xwiki-platform-cache-api-4.3-20121025.165403-177.jar xwiki-platform-cache-api-4.3-20121025.174540-178.jar xwiki-platform-cache-infinispan-4.3-20121025.165428-177.jar xwiki-platform-cache-infinispan-4.3-20121025.174606-178.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-icon-4.3-20121024.193826-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-icon-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-linkchecker-4.3-20121024.193846-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-macro-4.3-20121024.193051-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-macro-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-wikiword-4.3-20121024.193833-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-wikiword-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar
Thoses are perfectly normal and happen only in SNAPSHOT.
Are you sure ? I am looking on a 4.2 SNAPSHOT - http://maven.xwiki.org/snapshots/org/xwiki/manager/xwiki-manager-jetty-mysql... and I don't have these kind of duplications.
It depends if the jar comes from a remote repository or if they have been built on the same agent.
Regards, Sorin B.
Items statistics: /lib folder on SNAPSHOT : 126.6 MB - 445 Items /lib folder on Milestone 1: 126.3 MB - 392 Items
The odd thing is that I do not get any warnings, errors, stacktraces when starting the 4.3-SNAPSHOT. I wrote this mail to report the issue, because IMO this can cause serious issues.
Regards, Sorin B. _______________________________________________ devs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
-- Thomas Mortagne _______________________________________________ devs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
_______________________________________________ devs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
-- Thomas Mortagne
On Fri, Oct 26, 2012 at 4:21 PM, Sorin Burjan <[email protected]> wrote:
Hello everybody,
After the release of 4.3 Milestone 1, I wanted to start testing the new features but I ran into an issue ( http://jira.xwiki.org/browse/XWIKI-8365 ) when starting and accessing the Wiki based on 4.3 M1. After Marius helped me figure out the cause, it seemed that we had a jar duplication of Xalan in our Manager package. I have tested this on another machine and wasn't able to reproduce. Fabio also tested, without success, but the duplication is clear - I had 2 Xalan jars in my /lib folder (even on the machine where I had no errors).
After that, I started to look for other duplicates in my /lib folder. Below are my findings. Checked these 2 XWiki packages to be sure it's not package dependant: * xwiki-manager-jetty-hsqldb * xwiki-manager-jetty-mysql
Found the following JAR duplicates:
1) activation-1.1.1.jar activation-1.1.jar
2) commons-lang3-3.1.1jar commons-lang-2.6.jar
3) jdom-1.0 jdom-1.1.jar
4) plexus-utils-2.0.6.jar plexus-utils-2.0.7.jar
5) rome-0.9.jar rome-1.0.0.jar rome 1.0.jar
6) vorbis-java-core-0.1.jar vorbis-java-core-0.1-tests.jar
7) xercesImpl-2.9.1.jar xercesImpl-2.8.1.jar
After the release of 4.3 M1 I have also downloaded a 4.3-SNAPSHOT build (xwiki-manager-jetty-hsqldb-4.3-20121025.181227-95.zip). Besides the duplicates from above, I have also found a lot of XWiki jars duplicated. Note, the list if far from being complete !
xwiki-commons-classloader-api-4.3-20121024.173322-34.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-protocol-jar-4.3-20121024.173330-34.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-protocol-jar-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-component-observation-4.3-20121024.173347-34.jar xwiki-commons-component-observation-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-configuration-api-4.3-20121024.173413-34.jar xwiki-commons-configuration-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-context-4.3-20121024.173359-34.jar xwiki-commons-context-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-diff-api-4.3-20121024.173722-33.jar xwiki-commons-diff-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-platform-bridge-4.3-20121025.165136-181.jar xwiki-platform-bridge-4.3-20121025.174305-182.jar xwiki-platform-cache-api-4.3-20121025.165403-177.jar xwiki-platform-cache-api-4.3-20121025.174540-178.jar xwiki-platform-cache-infinispan-4.3-20121025.165428-177.jar xwiki-platform-cache-infinispan-4.3-20121025.174606-178.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-icon-4.3-20121024.193826-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-icon-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-linkchecker-4.3-20121024.193846-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-macro-4.3-20121024.193051-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-macro-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-wikiword-4.3-20121024.193833-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-wikiword-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar
Items statistics: /lib folder on SNAPSHOT : 126.6 MB - 445 Items /lib folder on Milestone 1: 126.3 MB - 392 Items
The odd thing is that I do not get any warnings, errors, stacktraces when starting the 4.3-SNAPSHOT. I wrote this mail to report the issue, because IMO this can cause serious issues.
Please tell me that I don't have to redo the release :) Just kidding... Well, duplication doesn't sound good. I wonder why, because the release step is pretty much automated (it's just a matter of running a script). -Fabio
Regards, Sorin B. _______________________________________________ devs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
On Fri, Oct 26, 2012 at 11:58 PM, Fabio Mancinelli <[email protected]> wrote:
On Fri, Oct 26, 2012 at 4:21 PM, Sorin Burjan <[email protected]> wrote:
Hello everybody,
After the release of 4.3 Milestone 1, I wanted to start testing the new features but I ran into an issue ( http://jira.xwiki.org/browse/XWIKI-8365 ) when starting and accessing the Wiki based on 4.3 M1. After Marius helped me figure out the cause, it seemed that we had a jar duplication of Xalan in our Manager package. I have tested this on another machine and wasn't able to reproduce. Fabio also tested, without success, but the duplication is clear - I had 2 Xalan jars in my /lib folder (even on the machine where I had no errors).
After that, I started to look for other duplicates in my /lib folder. Below are my findings. Checked these 2 XWiki packages to be sure it's not package dependant: * xwiki-manager-jetty-hsqldb * xwiki-manager-jetty-mysql
Found the following JAR duplicates:
1) activation-1.1.1.jar activation-1.1.jar
2) commons-lang3-3.1.1jar commons-lang-2.6.jar
3) jdom-1.0 jdom-1.1.jar
4) plexus-utils-2.0.6.jar plexus-utils-2.0.7.jar
5) rome-0.9.jar rome-1.0.0.jar rome 1.0.jar
6) vorbis-java-core-0.1.jar vorbis-java-core-0.1-tests.jar
7) xercesImpl-2.9.1.jar xercesImpl-2.8.1.jar
After the release of 4.3 M1 I have also downloaded a 4.3-SNAPSHOT build (xwiki-manager-jetty-hsqldb-4.3-20121025.181227-95.zip). Besides the duplicates from above, I have also found a lot of XWiki jars duplicated. Note, the list if far from being complete !
xwiki-commons-classloader-api-4.3-20121024.173322-34.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-protocol-jar-4.3-20121024.173330-34.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-protocol-jar-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-component-observation-4.3-20121024.173347-34.jar xwiki-commons-component-observation-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-configuration-api-4.3-20121024.173413-34.jar xwiki-commons-configuration-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-context-4.3-20121024.173359-34.jar xwiki-commons-context-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-diff-api-4.3-20121024.173722-33.jar xwiki-commons-diff-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-platform-bridge-4.3-20121025.165136-181.jar xwiki-platform-bridge-4.3-20121025.174305-182.jar xwiki-platform-cache-api-4.3-20121025.165403-177.jar xwiki-platform-cache-api-4.3-20121025.174540-178.jar xwiki-platform-cache-infinispan-4.3-20121025.165428-177.jar xwiki-platform-cache-infinispan-4.3-20121025.174606-178.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-icon-4.3-20121024.193826-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-icon-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-linkchecker-4.3-20121024.193846-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-macro-4.3-20121024.193051-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-macro-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-wikiword-4.3-20121024.193833-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-wikiword-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar
Items statistics: /lib folder on SNAPSHOT : 126.6 MB - 445 Items /lib folder on Milestone 1: 126.3 MB - 392 Items
The odd thing is that I do not get any warnings, errors, stacktraces when starting the 4.3-SNAPSHOT. I wrote this mail to report the issue, because IMO this can cause serious issues.
Please tell me that I don't have to redo the release :)
Just kidding...
Well, duplication doesn't sound good.
I wonder why, because the release step is pretty much automated (it's just a matter of running a script).
XEM depends on XE war and other jars (application-manager, wiki-manager, workspace-api, etc.). The "problem" is that when the XEM war is build the XE war is a _black box_ for Maven because it doesn't know what jars are included in the XE war so it can't do a proper dependency mediation, i.e. it can't filter automatically transitive jar dependencies of XEM that are already in the XE war so they get duplicated. This is a generic problem when you build a war based on another war and add new dependencies. Thanks, Marius
-Fabio
Regards, Sorin B. _______________________________________________ devs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
_______________________________________________ devs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
Hi Sorin, Thanks for noticing this! Could you please create a JIRA issue for the valid issues below, i.e. 1), 3), 4), 5), 6), 7), and mark them as blocker for 4.3M2? Thanks -Vincent On Oct 26, 2012, at 4:21 PM, Sorin Burjan <[email protected]> wrote:
Hello everybody,
After the release of 4.3 Milestone 1, I wanted to start testing the new features but I ran into an issue ( http://jira.xwiki.org/browse/XWIKI-8365 ) when starting and accessing the Wiki based on 4.3 M1. After Marius helped me figure out the cause, it seemed that we had a jar duplication of Xalan in our Manager package. I have tested this on another machine and wasn't able to reproduce. Fabio also tested, without success, but the duplication is clear - I had 2 Xalan jars in my /lib folder (even on the machine where I had no errors).
After that, I started to look for other duplicates in my /lib folder. Below are my findings. Checked these 2 XWiki packages to be sure it's not package dependant: * xwiki-manager-jetty-hsqldb * xwiki-manager-jetty-mysql
Found the following JAR duplicates:
1) activation-1.1.1.jar activation-1.1.jar
2) commons-lang3-3.1.1jar commons-lang-2.6.jar
3) jdom-1.0 jdom-1.1.jar
4) plexus-utils-2.0.6.jar plexus-utils-2.0.7.jar
5) rome-0.9.jar rome-1.0.0.jar rome 1.0.jar
6) vorbis-java-core-0.1.jar vorbis-java-core-0.1-tests.jar
7) xercesImpl-2.9.1.jar xercesImpl-2.8.1.jar
After the release of 4.3 M1 I have also downloaded a 4.3-SNAPSHOT build (xwiki-manager-jetty-hsqldb-4.3-20121025.181227-95.zip). Besides the duplicates from above, I have also found a lot of XWiki jars duplicated. Note, the list if far from being complete !
xwiki-commons-classloader-api-4.3-20121024.173322-34.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-protocol-jar-4.3-20121024.173330-34.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-protocol-jar-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-component-observation-4.3-20121024.173347-34.jar xwiki-commons-component-observation-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-configuration-api-4.3-20121024.173413-34.jar xwiki-commons-configuration-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-context-4.3-20121024.173359-34.jar xwiki-commons-context-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-diff-api-4.3-20121024.173722-33.jar xwiki-commons-diff-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-platform-bridge-4.3-20121025.165136-181.jar xwiki-platform-bridge-4.3-20121025.174305-182.jar xwiki-platform-cache-api-4.3-20121025.165403-177.jar xwiki-platform-cache-api-4.3-20121025.174540-178.jar xwiki-platform-cache-infinispan-4.3-20121025.165428-177.jar xwiki-platform-cache-infinispan-4.3-20121025.174606-178.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-icon-4.3-20121024.193826-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-icon-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-linkchecker-4.3-20121024.193846-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-macro-4.3-20121024.193051-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-macro-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-wikiword-4.3-20121024.193833-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-wikiword-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar
Items statistics: /lib folder on SNAPSHOT : 126.6 MB - 445 Items /lib folder on Milestone 1: 126.3 MB - 392 Items
The odd thing is that I do not get any warnings, errors, stacktraces when starting the 4.3-SNAPSHOT. I wrote this mail to report the issue, because IMO this can cause serious issues.
Regards, Sorin B. _______________________________________________ devs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
Hi Vincent, I have reported the issues you pointed out. Thanks, Sorin B. On Sat, Oct 27, 2012 at 7:55 PM, Vincent Massol <[email protected]> wrote:
Hi Sorin,
Thanks for noticing this!
Could you please create a JIRA issue for the valid issues below, i.e. 1), 3), 4), 5), 6), 7), and mark them as blocker for 4.3M2?
Thanks -Vincent
On Oct 26, 2012, at 4:21 PM, Sorin Burjan <[email protected]> wrote:
Hello everybody,
After the release of 4.3 Milestone 1, I wanted to start testing the new features but I ran into an issue ( http://jira.xwiki.org/browse/XWIKI-8365 ) when starting and accessing the Wiki based on 4.3 M1. After Marius helped me figure out the cause, it seemed that we had a jar duplication of Xalan in our Manager package. I have tested this on another machine and wasn't able to reproduce. Fabio also tested, without success, but the duplication is clear - I had 2 Xalan jars in my /lib folder (even on the machine where I had no errors).
After that, I started to look for other duplicates in my /lib folder. Below are my findings. Checked these 2 XWiki packages to be sure it's not package dependant: * xwiki-manager-jetty-hsqldb * xwiki-manager-jetty-mysql
Found the following JAR duplicates:
1) activation-1.1.1.jar activation-1.1.jar
2) commons-lang3-3.1.1jar commons-lang-2.6.jar
3) jdom-1.0 jdom-1.1.jar
4) plexus-utils-2.0.6.jar plexus-utils-2.0.7.jar
5) rome-0.9.jar rome-1.0.0.jar rome 1.0.jar
6) vorbis-java-core-0.1.jar vorbis-java-core-0.1-tests.jar
7) xercesImpl-2.9.1.jar xercesImpl-2.8.1.jar
After the release of 4.3 M1 I have also downloaded a 4.3-SNAPSHOT build (xwiki-manager-jetty-hsqldb-4.3-20121025.181227-95.zip). Besides the duplicates from above, I have also found a lot of XWiki jars duplicated. Note, the list if far from being complete !
xwiki-commons-classloader-api-4.3-20121024.173322-34.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-protocol-jar-4.3-20121024.173330-34.jar xwiki-commons-classloader-protocol-jar-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-component-observation-4.3-20121024.173347-34.jar xwiki-commons-component-observation-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-configuration-api-4.3-20121024.173413-34.jar xwiki-commons-configuration-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-context-4.3-20121024.173359-34.jar xwiki-commons-context-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-commons-diff-api-4.3-20121024.173722-33.jar xwiki-commons-diff-api-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-platform-bridge-4.3-20121025.165136-181.jar xwiki-platform-bridge-4.3-20121025.174305-182.jar xwiki-platform-cache-api-4.3-20121025.165403-177.jar xwiki-platform-cache-api-4.3-20121025.174540-178.jar xwiki-platform-cache-infinispan-4.3-20121025.165428-177.jar xwiki-platform-cache-infinispan-4.3-20121025.174606-178.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-icon-4.3-20121024.193826-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-icon-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-linkchecker-4.3-20121024.193846-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-macro-4.3-20121024.193051-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-macro-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-wikiword-4.3-20121024.193833-57.jar xwiki-rendering-transformation-wikiword-4.3-SNAPSHOT.jar
Items statistics: /lib folder on SNAPSHOT : 126.6 MB - 445 Items /lib folder on Milestone 1: 126.3 MB - 392 Items
The odd thing is that I do not get any warnings, errors, stacktraces when starting the 4.3-SNAPSHOT. I wrote this mail to report the issue, because IMO this can cause serious issues.
Regards, Sorin B. _______________________________________________ devs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
_______________________________________________ devs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
participants (5)
-
Fabio Mancinelli -
Marius Dumitru Florea -
Sorin Burjan -
Thomas Mortagne -
Vincent Massol