[xwiki-users] XOffice not downloading pages, missing attachments
Hi all, I personally fixed a few bugs in xoffice at the start of the year, which was released in XOffice 1.1. That was a long time ago, and we have not been using xoffice in the meantime (not building documentation yet). Now it is time to use it, and I'm having a lot of trouble. I would post a bug to JIRA if it were a single problem, but it appears that xoffice is fundamentally broken as I can't go longer than 30 seconds without hitting a road block. Does anyone use it? * For some pages with images, when I click Edit, the text appears with blank boxes for the images. * I am able to do the following: I edit a text-only page, and copy-paste in an image, then click Publish. Stop and restart Word, and it is able to Edit the page WITH THE IMAGE correctly. Seems strange that it works for this page, but not the other. * Some pages cannot be edited. I click Edit and it either doesn't seem to hear the button click, OR it will pop up "Opening page..." progress dialog, which never disappears. These are serious roadblock bugs, am I the only one seeing this, or is this so buggy that noone else is using it regularly? This is version 1.1 (released early 2011), with Word 2010, on Vista, freshly installed with not much else on the laptop. thanks Paul
Hi Paul, Indeed nobody is actively working on it at the moment and I was about to send a mail this week to propose to retire it and move it to the contrib repository since nobody in the xwiki committers are active on it and we want to keep a good quality on the software that we make available. The only alternative would be someone stepping up and willing to work on it and ensure it works with latest XWiki Enterprise versions. See that we have nobody active on it, we could throw a vote to grandfather that person as an XOffice committer so that he/she can easily work on it. Since you already fixed some bugs on it maybe you'd be interested to help out? Thanks a lot -Vincent On Oct 24, 2011, at 6:10 AM, Paul Harris wrote:
Hi all,
I personally fixed a few bugs in xoffice at the start of the year, which was released in XOffice 1.1. That was a long time ago, and we have not been using xoffice in the meantime (not building documentation yet). Now it is time to use it, and I'm having a lot of trouble.
I would post a bug to JIRA if it were a single problem, but it appears that xoffice is fundamentally broken as I can't go longer than 30 seconds without hitting a road block. Does anyone use it?
* For some pages with images, when I click Edit, the text appears with blank boxes for the images.
* I am able to do the following: I edit a text-only page, and copy-paste in an image, then click Publish. Stop and restart Word, and it is able to Edit the page WITH THE IMAGE correctly. Seems strange that it works for this page, but not the other.
* Some pages cannot be edited. I click Edit and it either doesn't seem to hear the button click, OR it will pop up "Opening page..." progress dialog, which never disappears.
These are serious roadblock bugs, am I the only one seeing this, or is this so buggy that noone else is using it regularly?
This is version 1.1 (released early 2011), with Word 2010, on Vista, freshly installed with not much else on the laptop.
thanks Paul
Hi, If you didn't start your documentation yet and you don't have any legacy documents, I'd recommend using a pure web solution like XWiki. If you use MS Office for advanced content, you will have issues pushing that content to the wiki anyway. I created XOffice a few years ago, when MS Office was a lot more dominant and web editors were still weak(including the one used by XWiki), but the situation is quite different now. Indeed there was no development on it for the past year. If you have critical issues with XOffice, it may be one of the following: - you are using a localized version of Office or Windows (there are older known issues with those) - there is a conflict with newer XWiki versions. The MS Office and Windows behavior and security settings are different for versions released on other languages. It doesn't make a lot of sense, but that's the way it is. I've been receiving quite a few requests for a new release. However I could only do some bug fixing only for the En/En environment, since it's a pain to test and fix other versions. Thanks, Florin Ciubotau On Mon, Oct 24, 2011 at 9:46 AM, Vincent Massol <[email protected]> wrote:
Hi Paul,
Indeed nobody is actively working on it at the moment and I was about to send a mail this week to propose to retire it and move it to the contrib repository since nobody in the xwiki committers are active on it and we want to keep a good quality on the software that we make available.
The only alternative would be someone stepping up and willing to work on it and ensure it works with latest XWiki Enterprise versions. See that we have nobody active on it, we could throw a vote to grandfather that person as an XOffice committer so that he/she can easily work on it.
Since you already fixed some bugs on it maybe you'd be interested to help out?
Thanks a lot -Vincent
On Oct 24, 2011, at 6:10 AM, Paul Harris wrote:
Hi all,
I personally fixed a few bugs in xoffice at the start of the year, which was released in XOffice 1.1. That was a long time ago, and we have not been using xoffice in the meantime (not building documentation yet). Now it is time to use it, and I'm having a lot of trouble.
I would post a bug to JIRA if it were a single problem, but it appears that xoffice is fundamentally broken as I can't go longer than 30 seconds without hitting a road block. Does anyone use it?
* For some pages with images, when I click Edit, the text appears with blank boxes for the images.
* I am able to do the following: I edit a text-only page, and copy-paste in an image, then click Publish. Stop and restart Word, and it is able to Edit the page WITH THE IMAGE correctly. Seems strange that it works for this page, but not the other.
* Some pages cannot be edited. I click Edit and it either doesn't seem to hear the button click, OR it will pop up "Opening page..." progress dialog, which never disappears.
These are serious roadblock bugs, am I the only one seeing this, or is this so buggy that noone else is using it regularly?
This is version 1.1 (released early 2011), with Word 2010, on Vista, freshly installed with not much else on the laptop.
thanks Paul
users mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/users
The killer feature is that normal users can create a document and copy-paste screenshots into a wiki document. That cannot be done with (almost) any web wiki editor I can find at present. Every person we showed it to loved it, and was willing to try editing a document on the wiki. Everyone we talked to about editing a wiki document via the web interface was simply not interested. We work with people who have almost no free time and are not interested in learning yet another program (ie web-wiki)... They know MS Word well, they are already read to write content. I don't understand why you aren't pushing this simple but powerful component more. I don't see it mentioned on wikipedia, or wikimatrix. I think if you made sure xoffice worked, and let people know it existed, then more people would use xwiki. Its a killer feature and I don't understand why its not on billboards on the sides of freeways. Regards, Paul On 24 October 2011 20:35, Florin Ciubotaru <[email protected]>wrote:
Hi,
If you didn't start your documentation yet and you don't have any legacy documents, I'd recommend using a pure web solution like XWiki. If you use MS Office for advanced content, you will have issues pushing that content to the wiki anyway. I created XOffice a few years ago, when MS Office was a lot more dominant and web editors were still weak(including the one used by XWiki), but the situation is quite different now.
Indeed there was no development on it for the past year. If you have critical issues with XOffice, it may be one of the following: - you are using a localized version of Office or Windows (there are older known issues with those) - there is a conflict with newer XWiki versions.
The MS Office and Windows behavior and security settings are different for versions released on other languages. It doesn't make a lot of sense, but that's the way it is. I've been receiving quite a few requests for a new release. However I could only do some bug fixing only for the En/En environment, since it's a pain to test and fix other versions.
Thanks, Florin Ciubotau
On Mon, Oct 24, 2011 at 9:46 AM, Vincent Massol <[email protected]> wrote:
Hi Paul,
Indeed nobody is actively working on it at the moment and I was about to send a mail this week to propose to retire it and move it to the contrib repository since nobody in the xwiki committers are active on it and we want to keep a good quality on the software that we make available.
The only alternative would be someone stepping up and willing to work on it and ensure it works with latest XWiki Enterprise versions. See that we have nobody active on it, we could throw a vote to grandfather that person as an XOffice committer so that he/she can easily work on it.
Since you already fixed some bugs on it maybe you'd be interested to help out?
Thanks a lot -Vincent
On Oct 24, 2011, at 6:10 AM, Paul Harris wrote:
Hi all,
I personally fixed a few bugs in xoffice at the start of the year, which was released in XOffice 1.1. That was a long time ago, and we have not been using xoffice in the meantime (not building documentation yet). Now it is time to use it, and I'm having a lot of trouble.
I would post a bug to JIRA if it were a single problem, but it appears that xoffice is fundamentally broken as I can't go longer than 30 seconds without hitting a road block. Does anyone use it?
* For some pages with images, when I click Edit, the text appears with blank boxes for the images.
* I am able to do the following: I edit a text-only page, and copy-paste in an image, then click Publish. Stop and restart Word, and it is able to Edit the page WITH THE IMAGE correctly. Seems strange that it works for this page, but not the other.
* Some pages cannot be edited. I click Edit and it either doesn't seem to hear the button click, OR it will pop up "Opening page..." progress dialog, which never disappears.
These are serious roadblock bugs, am I the only one seeing this, or is this so buggy that noone else is using it regularly?
This is version 1.1 (released early 2011), with Word 2010, on Vista, freshly installed with not much else on the laptop.
thanks Paul
users mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/users
_______________________________________________ users mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/users
participants (3)
-
Florin Ciubotaru -
Paul Harris -
Vincent Massol