Ecaterina Valica wrote:
Last, Lauren't experiment on http://laurent.myxwiki.org/xwiki/bin/view/ModificationVM/ shows everything at the top. I don't know how well or how badly it would work but it doesn't look too bad. I don't know, I'm not too fond of it. It's invisible information that appears only if you know how to make it visible. I am forced to click to access it. For example the tags are a pretty important piece information (that's why we're considering moving them at the top, to make it more visible), yet I have to click on a label to actually see them. Not to mention that they're unavailable without javascript.
Second, when this information appears, it blocks the main content. If we were to put the comments in the same way, as a visitor I wouldn't notice them, and when I open them up, I can't see the content anymore. How can I comment if I can't see what I'm commenting about?
I agree with Sergiu. It blocks the information and makes it in small little blocks. I don't like popups.
Tags should be at the bottom. My question is: do you think "Created by" should be displayed near the Tags or just put it in the "Information" tab?
IMO, "created by" is a pretty important information, maybe more that "last modified by". The information tab is hidden by default, so I think that it's better to put it near the tags. -- Sergiu Dumitriu http://purl.org/net/sergiu/