Hello Vincent, To add to the alternatives you presented, you could even use proper xar (http://code.google.com/p/xar/). It is actually a quite nice archive format, and it does have support for metadata, checksums, table of contents etc. On the other hand, it is not an established archive format, and I don't think there is a Java implementation for it, so the overhead of implementing this would be a lot more substantial than using zip or jar. Catalin On 2/3/07, Vincent Massol <[email protected]> wrote:
Hi Jeremi,
I'm +1 on my side but as you voted -1 we'll need to convince you to change your vote ;-) Let me give it a try below...
On Feb 3, 2007, at 9:41 AM, jeremi joslin wrote:
Hi,
-1
I'm not for changing to jar. it's not a Java archive, it's an XWiki Archive. I don't see the point to change. People will think it's javacode.
* JAR is an archive format. It can be used for lots of different things. There are even software that use JARs for their installation. * I really believe that in the future our applications will not be made only of XML files but will also contain other libraries (jar files) and java classes. For example imagine the IRC bot application. There are some xwiki pages but we also need the picoirc jar. We'll need to bundle all that together. * XWiki is a Java application so all users are familiar with the JAR format.
Of course we can use the XAR format for that. XAR looks nice because there's XWiki inside but there's a cost of inventing a new archive format: * It needs to be described * There needs to be tools for it (or people need to rename it to zip...). BTW if it's a zip we might as well name it zip... The problem with Zip is that it does not support meta data information such as the jar format does. And we need these... And there are APIs to get these metadata so we don't have to reimplement all the code (as we've done for the package.xml file). * It makes it difficult for the build (this is the same argument as above with tools) as all the existing plugins do not understand the XAR format so we have to reinvent all the tools... This is why I had to implement the xar handler and the xar plugin in our repository. It would make it much easier if it were an existing format such as JAR.
I think it would be much better to use an existing format (which we do except we're using Zip instead of JAR), already documented rather than invent a new one. There's no point in us hiding the underlying format we use by changing the extension. We might as well use that format's extension...
if you look at this page : http://filext.com/detaillist.php?extdetail=XAR there is some other software who are using this extension. So why XWiki can't use it?
Some people have thrown nuclear bombs in the past. Is that a good reason for others to do it? Probably not.
It's not because people are doing bad things that we have to follow them ;-)
Thanks -Vincent
On 2/3/07, Catalin Hritcu <[email protected]> wrote:
Hello all,
What would you think of using the JAR extension instead of (mis-) using XAR for XWiki applications, and using the JAR manifest for storing the information that is now stored in package.xml ? Any other way this can be fixed ?
Already created a JIRA task about this
http://jira.xwiki.org/jira/browse/XWIKI-802
but I would like to hear your opinions before spending the time to implement a change you might actually not want :)
Catalin
---------- Forwarded message ---------- From: Vincent Massol <[email protected]> Date: Feb 2, 2007 7:56 PM Subject: Re: [xwiki-dev] .xar Extension NOT Used Properly To: Catalin Hritcu <[email protected]>
Hi Catalin,
I think it's best to discuss all this on the list.
Also, I've provided some answer in JIRA.
Thanks -Vincent
On Feb 1, 2007, at 11:22 PM, Catalin Hritcu wrote:
Hi Vincent,
I created a JIRA issue for this and assigned it to myself: http://jira.xwiki.org/jira/browse/XWIKI-802
At the time I don't really know much about what needs to be changed to make it happen, but I'll look into it. Suggestions welcome :)
I guess we could use a JAR format and use information in the manifest to describe the content of an archive
Can you also be more precise about the information you want stored in the manifest? http://java.sun.com/j2se/1.5.0/docs/guide/jar/jar.html#JAR% 20Manifest According to this it seems that a manifest can store many things.
Regards, Catalin
On 1/31/07, Vincent Massol <[email protected]> wrote:
Hi Catalin,
See my other email on this topic. Basically I think I agree with you but we're currently focusing on releasing XWiki 1.0 and fixing bugs. this is an improvement request that will have to wait for quite long unless someone contributes a patch for it (including patches for the documentation ;-)).
Thanks -Vincent
On Jan 8, 2007, at 11:32 AM, Catalin Hritcu wrote:
The new way to import/export wiki pages is very useful. However, I think that using the .xar extension for the zip(!) archive is highly confusing. This because there is already a XAR(eXtensible ARchiver) archiving utility which uses the .xar extension for quite a while. And while now XAR is standalone, it will be quite probable used by the MacOSX package system in the future. Then download your archive will yield an error like this (safari automatically expands archives):
"Error opening xar archive: xwiki-1.0-beta-1.xar"
Links: http://www.opendarwin.org/projects/xar/ http://www.nabble.com/xar-in-Mac-OS-X-t2081148.html
<messagefooter.txt>
_____________________________________________________________________ ______ Yahoo! Mail réinvente le mail ! Découvrez le nouveau Yahoo! Mail et son interface révolutionnaire. http://fr.mail.yahoo.com
-- You receive this message as a subscriber of the xwiki- [email protected] mailing list. To unsubscribe: mailto:[email protected] For general help: mailto:[email protected]?subject=help ObjectWeb mailing lists service home page: http:// www.objectweb.org/wws
-- jeremi
-- You receive this message as a subscriber of the xwiki- [email protected] mailing list. To unsubscribe: mailto:[email protected] For general help: mailto:[email protected]?subject=help ObjectWeb mailing lists service home page: http://www.objectweb.org/ wws
___________________________________________________________________________ Yahoo! Mail réinvente le mail ! Découvrez le nouveau Yahoo! Mail et son interface révolutionnaire. http://fr.mail.yahoo.com
-- You receive this message as a subscriber of the [email protected] mailing list. To unsubscribe: mailto:[email protected] For general help: mailto:[email protected]?subject=help ObjectWeb mailing lists service home page: http://www.objectweb.org/wws