Fwd: Antw: XWiki: Testing for WIKI-1139

From: "Gunter Leeb" <Gunter.Leeb(a)mediaprint.at> Date: April 25, 2007 8:05:54 PM CEDT To: "Vincent Massol" <vincent(a)massol.net> Subject: Re: Antw: XWiki: Testing for WIKI-1139 Hi Vincent, Configuration: Just a very basic configuration. We just started a pilot project a few month ago. - MySQL DB on a Solaris server (copy of our Pilot/Production installation) - XWikiRC1 with your new jar on my development Windows PC pointing to this XWiki DB create for the old XWiki version. - Just a bare install run, I haven't even tweaked the skin, meaning, I am running with a skin (neither albatros nor dodo). Testsequence (Without your new jar): 1. Create a normal page WebHome in a TestSpace 2. Added a link [asdföäüasdf] in the page 3. Followed the link from the page and created a child page: The name is shortened and changed to "asdf???" - First Bug 4. Returning to the parent page: It still show the ? for "page not created". But following the link leads to the before created page in edit mode(!) - Second/Third Bug 5. Calling GUI Rename to "asdfasdföäüasdfasdf" -> claims to be successful but clicking on the link from the Rename-successmessage leads to the requested document could not be found page (the document name suddenly contains again ???) - Fifth Bug (That is now the opposite behavior of before: link claims ok, but page does not exist) 6. Refilling the new page asdfasdföäüasdfasdf with content. 7. Calling Rename velocity method (see the AdminTool script that I checked in in the CodeZone Snippet) 8. This time the rename to "asdfasdföäüasdfasf1" is successful, but following the link again leads to an empty page. Somehow the real page is lost. - Sixth Bug 9. Exported xar contains filenames with ? as well as a filename with really bad decoded Unicode characters. - Seventh Bug With your new jar, I suddenly get a much better behavior! Maybe your changes were not picked up correctly. Rename still fails with Pages that have documents attached that contain special characters. Actually, rename fails on various issues with attachments in the page (e.g. No row with the given identifier exists) It does not seem to like old failed attachments with 0 bytes (these actually also cannot be deleted !) Also, I have now rerun the entire script on a totally newly created XWiki installation with internal DB directly from the install script, again with your jar. This time I get ok behavior for any new szenarios I try out: - everything is working and behaving correctly (links, rename, delete) - imported the xar from the old configuration: The importer simply ignores documents in the form: "Main.MaCi.Änderungsdienst". Don't know whether this is because the Ä or the stupid name (our users really screwed up the structure in the old XWiki). - I would consider this also a bug. It should at least report that it could not import that page - and why. Now, I feel that pointing XWiki against an old Database might have caused this behavior and worse. Unfortunately, I cannot send you parts of the xar, since I don't want to ask for permissions to do that and explain everything :) and the data is from some important project. I hope this helps nevertheless. Regards, Gunter Hi Gunter, On Apr 25, 2007, at 3:51 PM, Gunter Leeb wrote: Thanks for trying it. Let's try to debug this... I think we can follow 2 leads: 1) In your patched version of RC1, can you try creating a new page with accents and then delete/rename it? 2) I'd like to reproduce your problem. Could you give me more information about your setup (i18n setup, database and container) and possibly it would be nice if you could send me a XAR export of your wiki (not the whole thing, maybe only a few pages) so that I can try it here. Could you also let me know exactly the steps you're performing? Thanks -Vincent PS: I'm ccing the dev list so that others can join us in debuggin this. > > Regards, > > Gunter > >>>> Vincent Massol <vincent(a)massol.net> 25.04.2007 14:30 >>> > Hi Gunter, > > I'm doing the release of XWiki 1.0 RC2 this afternoon and your bug > was one that I wanted to check out before releasing RC2. I don't know > > if you've seen but I have commented on http://jira.xwiki.org/jira/ > browse/XWIKI-1139. > > Do you think you could give it a quick try with the new JAR I've > uploaded for you? > > Thanks a lot > > -Vincent Massol > XWiki release manager