Hi Walid,
On 13 May 2014 at 10:23:42, walid yaich
(walid.yaich@gmail.com(mailto:walid.yaich@gmail.com)) wrote:
I'm sorry, i'm so serious, we're more than
300 persons in the company using XIWKI, si i'm pretty serious, if it's possible to
write a tool to migrate in 1 or 2 weeks, i'll probably do it.
BTW did you check the comments
at
http://extensions.xwiki.org/xwiki/bin/view/Extension/XWiki+Publication+Work…
?
Note that this extension is NOT developed by the XWiki dev team, it’s done by some
individual and is in no way supported by the XWiki dev team.
Also note that you don’t need this extension at all to implement a simple workflow in
XWiki. It can be done easily with the notion of XClass/XObjects natively but you’d need to
spend 1-2 days to understand these concepts. Actually these concepts are the main reason
people use XWiki and they allow you to go so much further than any other wiki can go.
If you’re serious and want to build something for the long run, I highly recommend that
you spend 2-3 days to get familiar with XWiki before making an impacting change for your
company.
Some tutorials on XClass/XObjects:
-
http://platform.xwiki.org/xwiki/bin/view/DevGuide/DataModel
-
http://platform.xwiki.org/xwiki/bin/view/DevGuide/FAQTutorial
Generally speaking you’ll find technical resources here:
http://platform.xwiki.org/xwiki/bin/view/DevGuide/WebHome
Maybe you're right, i didn't wait much, but i
spend much time trying to make it work and i didn't even understand the concept of
this extension, so maybe it's not well documented, in 1 days i get MediaWIKI with the
extension work properly, but i spend 3 days on XWIKI without any result, so maybe one
another reason is documentation :)
Yes that’s a good point. We always need to improve documentation. In this case however,
it’s beyond our control since this is an extension contributed by some individual and is
in no way managed by the XWiki dev team.
What could help would be to have a Workflow extension developed/supported by the XWiki dev
team. If enough people request this, this could be considered indeed.
BTW most people switch from Mediawiki to XWiki because they’re quickly limited by
Mediawiki on the “enterprise” aspects: fine-grained permissions, flat page hierarchy, LDAP
integration, Office integration, etc.
Thanks
-Vincent
2014-05-13 9:18 GMT+01:00
vincent@massol.net(mailto:vincent@massol.net) :
On 12 May 2014 at 23:59:35, walid yaich
(walid.yaich@gmail.com(mailto:walid.yaich@gmail.com)(mailto:walid.yaich@gmail.com))
wrote:
Hi everybody,
The reason is that we need a simple workflow in the wiki, the extension XWiki
Publication Workflow Application not working.
hmm that doesn’t seem a good reason to switch IMO… :)
You’re going to spend 10 times more time writing a migrator than you would to make the
Workflow Application work. AFAICS you’ve just posted an email about the Workflow issue
only a few minutes/hours ago and you’re not even waiting for the response before deciding
to migrate, that doesn’t look serious to me…
Thanks
-Vincent
> Well, actually i need to move from XWIKI to MediaWIKI, but the most
> difficult problem is the migration
>
> Would you please give me any clue about the easiest way to migrate the
> whole content from XWIKI to MediaWIKI
>
> Thanks in advance :)