I don't particularly like the recent alternative suggestions, the "w" is
either getting unwieldy or too wide, losing its original impact, and I'd drop my +1
for it in those cases.
To add my "hack", what if:
a) the "X" was made bigger and put "behind" the "Wiki" part
b) the "w" was a full W (straighter, not spread out)
c) the "k" was a full k (add the vertical line)
... then it might be more readable while still retaining a logo quality?
I didn't vote for 4 because I agree with some others: a) the pencils do imply drawing
more than collaborative writing; b) it seems to be lacking that "professional"
logo quality.
But maybe we're forcing something that shouldn't be forced. Could it be that
*none* of the proposed logos fit what you're after, and we're just choosing from
the best options presented?
Trevor
On Wed, 14 Apr 2010 11:58:54 +0300 Raluca Stavro wrote:
Hi all,
How about this alternative:
http://dev.xwiki.org/xwiki/bin/download/Community/LogoChallengeRound2/16-va….
I think that the W is readable now.
Raluca.