I presume that you mean that one page includes bits of several others. Takes a little hacking, but I've created a macro that includes the comments from the included pages and takes you to the individual pages to post comments. brain[sic]

If I understand correctly, you're just looking to comment seperately different chunks of a single document? You could try the following, though it assumes knowledge of velocity, querystrings, and classes: WARNING: I have not tried this myself, and as I've not tried anything like this, I have not checked if there is a better way around it. The main class object for the document contains just bare minimum to describe the page. Create a paragraph object. This is added by a user to the page to denote a paragraph/chunk for commenting. Create a paragraph_comment object. This is added by the user and pointed at the paragraph. Paragraph object details: -Text -Author -Date -Reference (you would populate this yourself, just use a mashup of username+date+randomNumeric; make sure to keep it short-ish). Paragraph_comment object details: -Text -Author -Date -Paragraph_reference You then use a link with a predefined querystring to create a new paragraph, and for creating a paragraph_comment; for paragraph_comment always pass in the "Reference" value as another querystring. Your class sheet would look something like (you would need to look at velocity examples around xwiki to get this right) #if($request.modifyparagraph) [code for handling paragraph additions] #elseif($request.modifycomment) [code for handling comment additions, and inserting $request.commentref into the paragraph_reference] #else [standard class object display] [if in view mode] [for-each paragraph object] [show paragraph] [for-each paragraph-comment**] [if Paragraph_reference = Reference show comment] [end for-each] [end for-each] [end if view mode] #end Doesn't sound simple with the bad way I explain it; but something along those lines would do the job. ** Not sure how to make this step efficient. Maybe setup an array with object numbers, remove the ones you use? -----Original Message----- From: Duncan Wilson [mailto:dwilson@berkeley.edu] Sent: 24 April 2007 20:54 To: xwiki-users(a)objectweb.org Subject: Re: [xwiki-users] Multiple comments sections on a page The idea was more along the lines of allowing users to comment on different parts of the same page. Think of a page with short book reviews for example. The page could have a number of single paragraph reviews, and after each one, users could post comments. The problem with the current setup is that, in the book review example, the comments for all the different reviews would be in a single section and it would be difficult and cumbersome to match comments to individual reviews. I realize this could be done simply by using multiple pages (one per review) but to preserve readability, I'd like to keep it all on a single page. Thank you, Duncan THOMAS, BRIAN M (ATTSI) wrote: xwiki-users(a)objectweb.org mailing list.