Thank you Sergiu! That information clarified the issue for me and helps me a lot in planning. I can see from the schema and id generation algorithms that object linking on document translation level is not too simple thing to change. Maybe that’s a little too heavy an issue for me to contribute, but of curiosity: do you have plans already how to solve this? Code in SVN? In any case I’m interested of the panel and page code you mentioned so please send it to me. Thanks! Petteri From: Sergiu Dumitriu [mailto:sergiu.dumitriu@gmail.com] Sent: 9. tammikuuta 2007 1:25 To: xwiki-users(a)objectweb.org Subject: Re: RE: [xwiki-users] Object properties' translations {quote} If you have more than one objects that must be translated on a page, you cannot use this function, because, as you see, there is no "number" parameter. However, you can write you own code that iterates over all objects. {/quote} Generally, it is recommended to have one main object per page. It is not a must, the final decision is yours, and it depends on the application profile. Sergiu On 1/9/07, Sergiu Dumitriu <HYPERLINK "mailto:sergiu.dumitriu@gmail.com"sergiu.dumitriu@gmail.com> wrote: Hi, Internally, a document has only one principal version, the one in the original language. Translations are just variants of that original document. Objects are attached to a document, meaning that an object is bound to the original document. This way you can't have (for the moment) objects attached to a translation. This is bound to change in 1.1 (or later). However, you can simulate this by using (indeed) a language property. In detail: 1. You must add a StringProperty for each class you would like to be translatable, named "lang" (or any other name you like) 2. Replace doc.getObject("MyClass") with doc.getObject("MyClass", "lang", $context.language[, true]). This return an object with the "lang" property set to the current language. Of course, you can replace $context.language with a specific language. The optional true parameter stands for failover, meaning that if an object with the requested language was not found, try again without the language filter. You cannot automatically translate objects with the current skin. If you are interested, I can give you the code for a panel and a page that can be used for this. If you have more than one objects that must be translated on a page, you cannot use this function, because, as you see, there is no "number" parameter. However, you can write you own code that iterates over all objects. On 1/9/07, HYPERLINK "mailto:petteri.karttunen@kuopionkonservatorio.fi" \npetteri.karttunen(a)kuopionkonservatorio.fi <HYPERLINK "mailto:petteri.karttunen@kuopionkonservatorio.fi" \n petteri.karttunen(a)kuopionkonservatorio.fi&gt; wrote: Yes, the wizard works correctly as far as I can see. The problem is perhaps more obvious with tagging for example (default XWiki.TagClass) ; if you want to tag the content of the same page differently depending on the page translation you have to add a TagClass instance for every translation and somehow bind them to translation in question(?) So is there a reason why the object's properties should be language independent? These are fundamental questions for me when planning the structure of my xwiki-based translation portal by no means impassable obstacles. Before fixing the custom class structure I would anyway very much like to hear your thoughts and developers' plans if the logic is going to stay this way in future releases. Thanks! Petteri -- You receive this message as a subscriber of the HYPERLINK "mailto:xwiki-users@objectweb.org" \nxwiki-users(a)objectweb.org mailing list. To unsubscribe: mailto:HYPERLINK "mailto:xwiki-users-unsubscribe@objectweb.org" \n xwiki-users-unsubscribe(a)objectweb.org For general help: mailto:HYPERLINK "mailto:sympa@objectweb.org" \nsympa(a)objectweb.org?subject=help ObjectWeb mailing lists service home page: HYPERLINK "http://www.objectweb.org/wws" \nhttp://www.objectweb.org/wws -- No virus found in this incoming message. Checked by AVG Free Edition. Version: 7.5.432 / Virus Database: 268.16.7/619 - Release Date: 7.1.2007 18:29 -- No virus found in this outgoing message. Checked by AVG Free Edition. Version: 7.5.432 / Virus Database: 268.16.7/619 - Release Date: 7.1.2007 18:29