Hi, I create livetables with doc.title as a column. By default, this column does not show as filterable. When I force filtering by "filterable:true", I can type in this field but nothing shows up as result. The property doc.name can be used and filtered as expected. I have created an example: http://playground.xwiki.org/xwiki/bin/view/Sandbox/Livetable Should I report his as a bug or did I overlook something?

On Tue, Feb 7, 2012 at 12:12 AM, Sergiu Dumitriu <sergiu(a)xwiki.com> wrote: > On 02/06/2012 10:59 AM, Joris Dirks wrote: >> >> Hi, >> >> I create livetables with doc.title as a column. By default, this >> column does not show as filterable. When I force filtering by >> "filterable:true", I can type in this field but nothing shows up as >> result. >> >> The property doc.name can be used and filtered as expected. >> >> I have created an example: >> http://playground.xwiki.org/xwiki/bin/view/Sandbox/Livetable >> >> Should I report his as a bug or did I overlook something? > > > There are two different things that usually act as "title", doc.title and > doc.displayTitle. The first one is an actual metadata field of the document, > persisted to the database, while the latter is a dynamic field computed from > different sources, including the doc.title field, headers in the content, > the document name, and, more recently, other fields selected by the sheet > used to display the objects in the document (a new feature of the new sheet > mechanism). Plus, it could even be more dynamic, as in text generated by > some Velocity code, in the most basic form a translation. > > Livetable filters work directly on the database, meaning that they translate > into sql conditions ("and doc.title like '%text introduced by the user%'"). > The doc.title column is special, since it's not exactly the doc.title > metadata, but a combination of doc.title and doc.displayTitle, so even > though the computed display title is displayed, filtering and sorting works > on the plain title. Given the very dynamic and unpredictable aspect of the > display title, it's impossible to write a correct sql filter that would > match the display title in all cases. > > For this reason, by default the title isn't filterable, since it won't meet > the user's expectations: it doesn't filter on the *displayed* title, but on > the internal title. What's more, it *can't* be configured so that it filters > on the right information all the time. For certain instances it would be > possible to actually make the field filterable, but only when your documents > really use the document title as the only source of the displayed title. > > For example, if you edit some of the displayed documents in wiki or wysiwyg > mode and enter something in the document title field (the one above the > content), you will be able to filter it in the livetable. > > I wouldn't report this as a bug, since it's a limitation that can't easily > be fixed, but what we could do is make more use of the document title. So > far we've been limited by the old sheet mechanism when developing > applications, so most applications define their own object property for the > title instead of using the document title, and even worse, their own > property for the main content, since the document content had to be reserved > for the sheet inclusion statement. Clear, thanks Sergiu. Though I'm not sure how a user (like me) could be aware of this. _______________________________________________ users mailing list users(a)xwiki.org http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/users