On Jun 5, 2008, at 4:35 PM, Arpit Jain wrote:
[snip]
After a quick glance, it does indeed
"seem" that Slidy might be
better
than S5 although that's not a fully given since they seem to have
the
same features. I like the fact that slidy is backed by the W3C
although it looks more like a one man-effort than a full-fledged
project. I searched quickly and couldn't find activity information on
these projects:
* number of committers,
* last commits
* date of last releases
Ideally we should choose a combination of the most active project +
the project with the best future.
All I can find about Slidy is dated 2006 which is worrying me a
bit. I
couldn't find a download page for it either.
Slidy's download link is mentioned in Slide No.
5<http://www.w3.org/Talks/Tools/Slidy/#%285%29>of its tutorial. You
can download it from
here <http://www.w3.org/Talks/Tools/Slidy/slidy.zip>. I know they
should
have placed it specifically somewhere else where it should have
been easy
to locate.
Pb is that we don't know what version it is and when it was released.
This is really amateurish work... ;)
Regarding S5
seems like someone is continuing the work:
http://www.netzgesta.de/S5/
(
http://www.netzgesta.de/S5/download.php)
Do you think you could find some activity information?
To be honest right now I don't like any of these project since:
* they don't seem to have a community
* I don't see bug trackers for them
* I don't see SCM access to the sources
Thus I'm not convinced about their futures so far. WDYT?
And yes, you are right. I also couldn't find any work going on in
this
direction on both of these projects. For S5, there are few people
who are
working independently and have developed few extensions as you
mentioned.
They tried to collaborate the efforts at
http://s5project.org/ but
this one
is also not updated since 2006.
For Slidy, there has been no update. It's mentioned by Dave Raggett
at few
places(including the Slidy tutorial) that he is working on a Wysywig
editor
to create Slidy presentation. Image of the alpha version
here<http://www.w3.org/Talks/Tools/Slidy/editor/editor-
screenshot1.png>.
But there has been no update on this one also.
I found couple of more similar projects on netzgesta's
site<http://www.netzgesta.de/S5/download.php>which are
Slideous <http://goessner.net/articles/slideous/> and
AJAX-S<http://www.robertnyman.com/2005/11/13/proudly-presenting-ajax-s/
but
they have the same problem of no
contributions and updates.
I think Slidy and S5 are our best bet and we should choose one of
them and
start working. And they contain most of the features that a "Simple"
presentation requires.
Also, both of them use similar markups, therefore, modifying the Slide
Generator code(which I would be writing) for the other one won't be
that
difficult.
What say?
Yes, we should have an interface to isolate us from either S5 or Slidy
so that we don't don't have a single dependency on it in our code
(beyond the interface implementation).
It would be cool if this interface could also be implemented using
Google Presentation API for example.
Thanks
-Vincent
Other frameworks:
SlideML <http://slideml.bitflux.ch/> => Download link not working.
Thanks
- Arpit
>
> Thanks
> -Vincent
>
>> I plan to finalize the structure and markup to be used by the end of
>> this
>> weekend. Then I will start working on creating the GUI interface. I
>> would
>> finish most of the features of it like Slide creation, Slide
>> navigation,
>> Insert images/hyperlink, Bullets, Changing color etc. by first or
>> second
>> week of July. I will keep posting my updates here.
>>
>> Then I will work on other features like creating templates,
>> converting to
>> PDF, changing background/layout of slides. Some of these
>> functionalities are
>> not available in Slidy, so I would have to modify its code to
>> include them.
>>
>>
>> -Arpit Jain
>>
>>
>> On Mon, May 26, 2008 at 1:33 PM, Vincent Massol <vincent(a)massol.net>
>> wrote:
>>
>>> Hi GSOCers,
>>>
>>> The bonding period is over and today starts your GSOC project
>>> period.
>>> Note that this doesn't mean you should drop whatever JIRA issue you
>>> had assigned to yourself. Please continue to work on it and
>>> *finish*
>>> it. It's important.
>>>
>>> However it means that from today onwards you can start working on
>>> your
>>> project. The most important thing to do is send an email on the
>>> xwiki
>>> dev list explaining:
>>> * what architecture you're envisioning to use for your project. If
>>> you
>>> have doubts/questions please mention them.
>>> * A general planning breaking down the high level tasks you have to
>>> do
>>> and giving deadlines for each. That'll help you reach your
>>> objectives
>>> and in that manner we (the mentors and the community in general)
>>> can
>>> also help you by reviewing milestone objectives and helping you
>>> achieve them
>>> * what are your next steps and when you're planning to have them
>>> done
>>> * Any questions you have
>>>
>>> Please use the mailing list over IRC and especially over direct
>>> skype/
>>> chat. Again it's really important that you work with the community.
>>> The success of your SOC depends on that as much as finishing your
>>> project.
>>>
>>> Thanks, good luck and have fun!
>>> -Vincent on behalf of the XWiki mentors