28 Nov
2008
28 Nov
'08
10 a.m.
On Fri, Nov 28, 2008 at 8:31 AM, Marius Dumitru Florea
<mariusdumitru.florea(a)xwiki.com> wrote:
I'm just saying that Vincent is not exactly the average user here :)
What I find sometimes annoying is going back and forth through a wizard.
I admit a wizard fills more secure the first few times it's being used,
See ! :)
I'm not a big fan of step wizards thus I'm
more into proposal 3. See
other comments below.
The user would be forced to use the mouse in order to see the preview.
Yes and I don't see how it could be different in proposals 3) and 4),
displaying images in the tree ?
- as a user I
prefer to see all options to understand where I'll find
The WYSIWYG addresses power users also.
the feature I'm looking for
s/user/power user/ - it's one click less
IMHO an extra click is only a problem if the user has to think where
to click and why to click.
I agree that 2 or more extra clicks are a problem but only one, with
the action button always at the very same place, no. but for me it can get annoying the more I'm using
it.
Of course having a wizard with a lot of mandatory steps would be a
pain but there's only 2 of them here.
There's a "pro" I have forgotten in the list :
Having those 2 steps is a good thing considering that we'll use the
same dialog for insertion / deletion. When you'll edit a
link/image/etc you'll first see the options dialog and won't have to
load/see the wiki tree. Of course you'll be able to go back to the
first step but in most of the cases (imo) you won't have to.
JV.