Re: [xwiki-devs] [VOTE] Use the new security-authorization module per default in XWiki 5.0

Hi devs, We have a new (component based) authorization module since a while now, and I think 5.0 is the perfect time to introduce it as the default right service. First, I simply propose to change the default in xwiki.cfg: xwiki.authentication.rightsclass=org.xwiki.security.authorization.internal.XWikiCachingRightService (Later, I propose that we deprecate that bridge and that we create a friendly (xwiki oriented) interface over the more generic org.xwiki.security.authorization.AuthorizationManager. But leave this for a later proposal.) So this vote is about changing the default in xwiki.cfg before 5.0M2. pros: - improved performance, since the new service is using caching techniques and a single page load required lots of calls to it. - ability for extension to add new rights - define right declaratively - separate method for checking and verifying right (throws opposed to boolean return) - fix some long waiting bugs like XWIKI-5174, XWIKI-6987, as well as some unstated ones - possibility to easily solve issues like XWIKI-4491 - no more admin right per default - being in good position to improve it and release dependencies to oldcore for security matters. - possibility for third party to adapt the right settler to their special needs (right decision is plugable) - a consistant right evaluation with very few exception that could be explained and documented cons: - no more admin right per default, but since we have DW, the initial setup is no more a problem, and advanced users may use superadmin. - groups are only checked from the user wiki, not from the accessed entity wiki. - may exhibit some other minor differences compare to existing implementation (but mostly consistency fixes) - test could be improved, critical part (right, settler, data structure, cache) are covered at almost 100%, api at 60%, this is probably better than the old right service - documentation should be improved, but this is not worse than the old one anyway Since I use the new module in all my production servers for several months with success, and I really think that if we do not do it now we will never go ahead, here is my big +1 WDYT ? -- Denis Gervalle SOFTEC sa - CEO eGuilde sarl - CTO _______________________________________________ devs mailing list devs(a)xwiki.org http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs