Re: [xwiki-devs] [VOTE] URLs and encoding

Hi devs, The short version: Should we always use UTF-8 for encoding and decoding URLs, regardless of the wiki encoding, for better compliance with web standards? The long version: By definition, URLs can only contain ASCII characters, everything else must be converted to their corresponding bytes and escaped as %XY escapes. The problem is that "their corresponding bytes" implies a charset + encoding, and no specification *enforces* a specific pair, although it is *recommended* to use Unicode + UTF8, to comply with the modern tendency of the web in general. Traditionally, XWiki has been using the same encoding as the configured global wiki encoding for the URLs, which means that before 1.9, when we switched to UTF8 as the default wiki encoding, all URLs were using the ISO-8859-1 encoding. Since the switch to UTF-8, URLs are also using the UTF-8 encoding by default, although the wiki encoding can be changed. Now, since 2.1, a bugfix accidentally changed the behavior, so that parsing back URLs always uses the UTF-8 encoding, even though composing URLs continues to use the wiki encoding. This is a bug, which prevents changing the encoding to anything other than UTF-8, and it should be fixed. Now, we have two options: 1. Reintroduce the old behavior, so that URLs always use the wiki encoding. This is a direct bugfix. 2. Also change the encoding part, so that UTF-8 is always used. This is an improvement, going towards better compliance with web standards. Personally I think that the second option is the better one, but it requires a vote, since it has a few drawbacks. Advantages: + better compliance with web standards, since UTF-8 is the recommended encoding for URLs (although not imposed) + support for a wider range of document names, since UTF-8 allows full-unicode document names, while ISO-8859-1 limits names to latin1 characters + better support from browsers, since entering accented characters directly in the address bar encodes the URL sent to the server using UTF-8, and decoding the URL also assumes UTF-8; this means that a document named "é" will be printed as .../view/Main/%E9 and will have to be entered the same way in the address bar when ISO-8859-1 is used, and as .../view/Main/é when UTF-8 is used Drawbacks: - by default Tomcat uses ISO-8859-1 as the encoding for URLs, so the Tomcat configuration will have to be changed as in http://platform.xwiki.org/xwiki/bin/view/AdminGuide/Encoding#HTomcat - some existing bookmarks will not work anymore once the encoding is changed +1 for option 2 from me,

-- Sergiu Dumitriu http://purl.org/net/sergiu/ _______________________________________________ devs mailing list devs(a)xwiki.org http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs