28 Jun
2008
28 Jun
'08
9:14 a.m.
Hi,
It's never late to give feedback, you're welcome any time :)
* I personally agree with you that the icons are a little bit to big,
but this can be fixed for the RC.
* Yes, you are right about the width of the tables, this problem will
also be solved before the final release.
* However, I don't agree with your idea about modifying users and groups
sections. I didn't understand much from your proposal below, since some
of the phrases aren't finished. Btw, it used to be Users & Groups
category together but we decided it's best to separate them, especially
when you have a very large wiki, with hundreds of users and groups to
search for. More, I don't understand your concept of adding a group to a
user and setting rights by clicking on the group's name...it just
doesn't seem natural to me. So I find your proposal a bit weird, but
this is only my opinion.
* What exactly do you find puzzling about space administration? It
contains (for now) 3 entries: the Presentation (where you can customize
the layout at space level), the rights to be set at space level, and
panel wizard, which allows you do choose how to display the panels
(right, left, none or both). It it seems cluttered, you can just remove
both panel columns and make more room. In a future release, these space
sections will include more application admin pages, like the Wiki
Administration contains now (Blog, Photos etc).
Thanks,
Evelina
Squirrel wrote:
Hi guys,
I know, it's kind of late to give you a general feedback for the new admin
interface, nevertheless I'd like to point some things out:
* The icons are nice, but way too big (tested on 1280x800, FF3, Opera &
Konqueror)
* In the 'Rights' section the two tables don't have the same width, though
the same content and space is unnecessarily wasted (this is true for most
sections) ..
* I miss some structure, categories...everything seems now cluttered...I
know, underneath not much changed, but compared with the previous surface
it's now quite obvious to me. Ie. the 'User' and the 'Group' section.
They
just make no sense anymore. I guess you could easily integrate the 'Group'
section into the 'User' section and call it 'User Administration'. Some
clickable filter (titles like 'username' 'groupname' etc.) and a search
input-field. And instead editing the group and add a new user to the group,
you add the group(s) to the user. If you edit a group (click on the groups
name) you will then not adding users but change the rights for the group
('Rights' section)....if you add a group you give it a name and set the
groups rights.
* I miss a content overview...this interferes somehow with spaces, pages and
rights...
* The space preferences are (still) puzzling to me, although I don't have a
better solution in my sleeves...
Hmm...I don't have enough time *right now* to explain in deep what I
mean...actually I'm not quite sure about what I mean either...it's just a
feeling that there is something not quite right...I don't know. I'm sorry
I'm this late with my input...
I hope it's not useless and if so, feel free to ignore this post ;-)
I'm testing now the functional part of it.
Cheers,
Squirrel
_______________________________________________
devs mailing list
devs(a)xwiki.org
http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs