----- "Fabio Mancinelli" <fabio.mancinelli(a)xwiki.com> wrote:
On 08/30/2010 05:46 PM, Ecaterina Valica wrote:
Hi Fabio,
This means I am iterating and I gather feedback and depending on
that
feedback we must agree on a version.
Ok. I thought that "old" meant "superseded by" :)
On a wiki platform, what do you think is more
relevant: the user or
page
centric approach?
What are the things that make this version (the page centric one)
not to fit
the Wiki 3.0 specification?
What is missing basically boils down to the "Share your thoughts" box
Yes, user updates should be mixed in the stream ultimately, I think.
and the type of information we can convey with it.
The "user centric" view, imho, is also useful because a "user" could
also be an application that sends events (e.g., meeting or deadlines
reminders, etc.) that can be shown in a more natural way in a user
centric view. Basically even applications might share their thoughts
through the activity stream ;)
I completely agree with the last sentence. BUT I think it's not incompatible with a
document/user mixed-approched (I don't think either full document-centric or full
user-centric can embrace the versatility of XWiki)
I see two types of entries :
* Document updates. Basically what is currently in latest proposal (though I would add
little user pictures here as well, even before the click). This is KM, collaboration,
etc.
* Users/applications updates. Those are less structured, more a-la facebook.
I see something like
http://incubator.myxwiki.org/xwiki/bin/view/Improvements/ActivityStreamMixed (raw picture,
would have to be refined)
(Note I also have right-padded a bit more the comment/annotation/pencil/etc icons that are
on top of user photos, I think they were a bit too masked by them)
Jerome.
Jerome missed the avatars, so if you did too,
please try to expand
the items
in the prototype (when you hover the items an
arrow appears in the
right
part suggesting that the item can be expanded ).
Yes I missed them too, but then I saw it.
Still the previously mentioned types of information are not available
anymore.
Thanks,
Fabio
_______________________________________________
devs mailing list
devs(a)xwiki.org
http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs