Re: [xwiki-commits] r2817 - xwiki-sandbox

Hi Stephane, This sounds cool. Could you please send a short email explaining what this is for, what you're planning to do with this, who's going to work on this, architecture decisions taken, etc? Also I've see you've imported sources from org.semanticdesktop.*. I have some questions regarding this: 1) Why do we need this library? 2) Why don't we depend on a JAR version of it rather than on source? 3) What is the license of it? 4) It looks like JDK 1.5 code... but I guess we're going to standardize on JDK 1.5 now... A general comment: while this sounds cool, I think you're dumping a LOT of files and this makes it almost impossible for anyone else to participate in this refactoring which isn't good for you as it may mean you'll have to do the whole coding yourself... ;-) I would have rather had a discussion first explaining what you wanted to do, what architecture, how does it fit with the 2.0 architecture, etc. Of course we can and should do that now but still it's hard to review that huge commit... at least for anyone not having 3-4 full days ahead of him... :) All that said, I'm happy we're getting traction on this :) Thanks -Vincent On Apr 15, 2007, at 10:10 PM, St??phane Lauri??re wrote: