On Feb 4, 2010, at 11:44 AM, Thomas Mortagne wrote:
On Thu, Feb 4, 2010 at 11:34, Vincent Massol
<vincent(a)massol.net> wrote:
On Feb 4, 2010, at 11:29 AM, Thomas Mortagne wrote:
On Thu, Feb 4, 2010 at 11:17, Vincent Massol
<vincent(a)massol.net> wrote:
On Feb 4, 2010, at 11:08 AM, Thomas Mortagne wrote:
> On Thu, Feb 4, 2010 at 09:25, Vincent Massol <vincent(a)massol.net> wrote:
>> Hi devs,
>>
>> I'm going to work on this and put the code in the xwiki-script module.
>>
>> There's only Thomas who voiced his positive opinion on the proposal below.
Could you please let me know if you don't agree (or even if you do, actually).
>>
>> Just to complement a bit the proposal here are what some existing mapping would
become (in Velocity for the example):
>>
>> * $syntaxFactory --> $services.rendering.syntaxFactory
>> * $officeimporter --> $services.officeImporter.importer
>> * $ooconfig --> $services.officeImporter.openOfficeConfiguration
>> * $oomanager --> $services.officeImporter.openOfficeManager
>> * $captchaservice --> $services.captcha
>>
>> Note 1: It might be good to split xwiki-officeimporter into 2 modules: one for
the importer and one for managing an openoffice server (xwiki-openoffice). In this case
the mapping would be:
>>
>> * $officeimporter --> $services.officeImporter
>> * $ooconfig --> $services.openOffice.configuration
>> * $oomanager --> $services.openOffice.manager
>>
>> Note 2: It might be good to force the format
$services.<modulename>.<object to get>.<method> since otherwise it would
mean putting all the APIs into a single object. I'm not sure on this, we need to
decide.
>
> Not sure how it will work, what would be $services.<modulename> ?
For ex for the office importer asiri has a OfficeImporterVelocityBridge (which is the
object that $services.offcieimproter would return)
> I
> think Velocity stop at the dot and will not try to call
> $services.get("rendering.syntaxFactory") but
> $services.get("rendering").get("syntaxFactory") but I'm not
100% sure
> about that.
I'm pretty sure it's fine: $services.moduleName.whatever() is equivalent to
$services.get("moduleName").whatever()
I know and that's exactly what is said but that's not what I'm talking
about here, in your proposal you have
$services.module.submodule.whatever()
($services.rendering.syntaxFactory.whatever()) and not
$services.moduleName.whatever() so I'm asking what java object will
represent will be $services.module ? since $services.module.submodule
will be the registered service component.
$services.module.submodule.whatever() is equivalent to
$service.get("module").get("submodule").whatever().
Sure but again that's not what i'm asking: in your proposal what is
$service.get("module")
ScriptServiceManager has a get method that does a CM lookup on ScriptService with
"module" as the hint.
So $service.get("module") will give you an object implementing ScriptService and
that can implement any business methods too.
and what is
$service.get("module").get("submodule") ? Is the module will
register
a unique ScriptService which internally has sub services or is there a
ModleScriptService and ScriptService to differentiate module and
service ? Or is ServiceManager emulate a module object in
$service.get("module") by putting in it all the ScriptService with
hint starting with "module." ? Theses solution are very differents
things from module developer POV, that's why i'm asking.
So $service.get("module").get("submodule") would mean calling a get
method on the Script Service object.
I've just committed a first version. Let's continue our discussion based on what
I've committed.
Thanks
-Vincent
>
> See
http://velocity.apache.org/engine/releases/velocity-1.6.2/user-guide.html#p…
>
> Thanks
> -Vincent
>
>>> Thanks
>>> -Vincent
>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> Note 3: I'll need to expose some new script APIs from the
xwiki-model module too to allow velocity scripts to manipulate Entity References, so I
propose:
>>>>>
>>>>> *
$services.model.referenceResolver.getCurrentResolver()/getDefaultResolver(), etc
>>>>> *
$services.model.referenceSerializer.getDefaultSerializer()/getCompactSerializer(), etc
>>>>>
>>>>> Note 4: In due time, we'll deprecate/remove $msg and $util from
the velocity context. When the new xwiki-localization module gets done, it'll expose
script APIs through $services.localization.*
>>>>>
>>>>> Note 5: What do we do with Velocity Tools that are exposed directly
in the Velocity context? IMO we should leave them in the velo context directly since
they're not Script Services (they're only specific to velocity).
>>>>
>>>> +1, it's very specific to velocity it should keep velocity tool
style
>>>> (i.e. as direct binding)
>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> Note 6: $doc, $xwiki, $xcontext stay in the script context for now.
They'll be replaced one day by new model objects and $xwiki will be replaced by $wiki
and all non model services will be accessible through $services.*
>>>>>
>>>>> WDYT?
>>>>>
>>>>> Thanks
>>>>> -Vincent
>>>>>
>>>>> On Aug 5, 2009, at 5:47 PM, Vincent Massol wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>>> Hi,
>>>>>>
>>>>>> This is following the proposal done here some time ago:
>>>>>>
http://markmail.org/message/nnybto3mluvp2rov
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Since we now have a generic Script notion we need to revisit it
in that light. Also we really need to implement it now since more and more components are
put in the velocity context (office importer, syntax factory, etc) and we need to bring
some order.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Here's a new generic proposal:
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Short term
>>>>>> ========
>>>>>>
>>>>>> * The variable "services" is bound in the script
context. For ex in Velocity: $services
>>>>>> * The Services object (ScriptServiceManager) has a ScriptService
get(String serviceName) method which returns the service
>>>>>> * We use the namespace: services.<module
name>.<method>. Each module provides only one service entry point.
>>>>>> * ScriptService interface (empty interface) represents a service
to be bound in the context
>>>>>> * ScriptServiceManager.get() looks for all components of role
ScriptService and returns the component matching the the name as the component hint.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Ex:
>>>>>>
>>>>>> @Component("mymodule")
>>>>>> public class MyModuleScriptService implements ScriptService,
MyModuleBusinessInterface
>>>>>> {
>>>>>> public void myMethod() {}
>>>>>> }
>>>>>>
>>>>>> In script:
>>>>>>
>>>>>> {{velocity}}
>>>>>> $services.mymodule.myMethod
>>>>>> {{/velocity}}
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Medium term
>>>>>> ==========
>>>>>>
>>>>>> * We handle @authorization(Authorization.PROGRAMMING) annotations
to check for access rights. To do this in ScriptServiceManager.get() we use a Dynamic
Proxy to implement MyModuleBusinessInterface (we probably need a
ScriptService.getInterface() method to make it unambiguous). The Dynamic Proxy checks the
annotation before proxying to the real object.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> WDYT?
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Thanks
>>>>>> -Vincent
>>>>>>
>>>>>> PS: This is to answer Sergiu's question about where is
getAvailableParserSyntaxes() from my other mail... ;) Answer: It would be in
RenderingScriptService.