1 Jul
2015
1 Jul
'15
10:41 a.m.
On Fri, Jun 26, 2015 at 7:48 PM, Ecaterina Moraru (Valica)
<valicac(a)gmail.com> wrote:
Hi,
Some conclusions with the current votes:
Q0. **Nested Spaces in model**
No matter the UI decisions we still need to take, we are implementing
Nested Spaces for 7.2 roadmap. The future is still uncertain regarding
changing the model to accommodate Nested Documents, since we can simulate
ND using NS.
7 x (+1) 'Already decided'
Q1. **NS vs ND in the UI**
Q1.1 The majority agreed that since the final purpose are ND, we should
display ND in the UI, since it simplifies the mental model of the user.
This implies removing the Space concept from the UI.
7 x (+1) 'Already decided'
Q1.1.1 A consequence is hiding the
'WebHome' name in the UI.
6 x (+1) , 1 x (+0) 'Already decided'
Q1.2 Although the default should be ND, the question is if we want to give
the option to display NS in the UI. This would be implemented as an
advanced and technical option. The main problem is that we might need to
provide UI alternatives for several components (menus, create step, etc.)
6 x (-0) -> so we will not give an additional option to display NS in the
UI (see Terminal Pages)
Q2. **Parent/Child**
Parent/Child deprecation is a bit more difficult to calculate, since the
votes are mixed depending on the definition of 'deprecation', not clearly
stated the vote or given partially votes.
The conclusion is that in order not to confuse the user, we should
deprecate the P/C concept.
It will not be dropped from the DB (and will be available if someone wants
to create additional extensions to display it), but it will not be
displayed by default in the UI, since breadcrumbs/trees will display the ND.
Q2.1 Deprecate the notion of Parent/Child.
Q2.1.1 Provide a migration to transform the relation into NS/ND. Problem:
the old URLs[A] (bookmarks) are broken + the user is stuck with long
URLs[B] if he wants to keep the hierarchy. Additionally we might need to
provide an extension/configuration to transform into short URLs [B -> C].
Q2.1.2 Don't migrate: the parent/child hierarchy will be lost but the old
URLs[A] (bookmarks) will be kept. The user needs
to use NS/ND to create
hierarchies.
The 'migration' got:
3 x (-1)
1 x (-0)
1 x (+1)
Don't 'migrate' got:
2 x (+1)
2 x (+0)
The general feeling is that we don't need to provide such a migration
automatically. Script could be put into place (to transform P/C into ND),
but this should be applied on a case by case scenario.
Other needed script is in order to transform the existing pages from A/B
into A/B/WebHome.
Q2.2 Don't deprecate the notion of Parent/Child.
Q2.2.1 Provide a configuration in the Administration to switch the
breadcrumbs between displaying Parent/Child or NS/ND. We might need to
provide UI alternatives for several components (tree, breadcrumb
navigation, create, etc.)
Configuration between P/C and NS/ND:
4 x (-0)
1 x (+0)
1 x (+1)
The general feeling is that this is not needed. There could be an option
from UI/config to turn the P/C relation on, but it would be off by default.
Q3. **Terminal Pages**
Since we will have 'Terminal Pages' and 'Non Terminal Pages', it was
proposed to have an option in the Profile or associate this behavior with
the Advanced user role, in order to display a checkbox ('Create a page
without children') in the 'Create Page' step.
Additional, for the users that have this checkbox selected, if they land on
a non existing page, instead of being transferred directly into Edit mode,
when they click 'You can edit this page to create it', they will be
directed to the 'Create Page' step, in order to be able to select the
'Create a page without children' checkbox. (Use case mentioned by Vincent).
Terminal and Non Terminal pages will be displayed in
the Tree, by having
associated an expand icon or not.
This is not enough / right. There's a difference between pages that
don't have child documents (currently) and pages that can't have child
documents (because they don't support it).
Maybe there are other ideas regarding 'Terminal Pages'?
Please let me know if I summarized correctly and if others want to cast
additional votes.
Thanks,
Caty
_______________________________________________
devs mailing list
devs(a)xwiki.org
http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs