Re: [xwiki-devs] [Proposal] Stopping the 4.4M1 release till tests are all passing - Commando mode

Hi devs, We have too many test failures on http://ci.xwiki.org/view/Functional%20Tests/ and too many emails sent by Jenkins on the list. It has become a nightmare and it's impossible to perform a release anymore with a good confidence it's going to work. This is all the more bad that we're ending the 4.x cycle. Thus I propose to do the following: * Don't release 4.4M1 till all tests are passing with no more flickers (say the tests should all pass during 10 full builds for example) * Create a Commando unit in charge of solving the flickers. Since I've already discussed this with Marius I propose that Marius and myself be the first 2 members. If anyone else would like to help please reply to this mail and join us. * This commando unit gives itself 1 full week to solve the flickers (ie till the 21st of December). We'll decide what to do next if we fail to achieve our goal after that deadline. * We start by creating a branch for 4.4M1 so that we isolate ourselves from the rest of the devs who continue to work for 4.4RC1 (reminder: only important bug fixes should go in 4.4RC1) * When we have fixed all flickers on the 4.4M1 branch we merge the changes to both master and the stable-4.3 branch * At the end of next week we also propose a strategy so that this mess doesn't happen again in the future WDYT?

Thanks -Vincent Note: We need to release 4.3.1 ASAP so this strategy above will not apply to 4.3.1. For 4.3.1 Edy will need to figure out if all the failing tests are real issues or test issues. I think Edy could do this by a combination of running them locally and doing some manual tests where they also fail locally. Edy WDYT?

_______________________________________________ devs mailing list devs(a)xwiki.org http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs