Re: [xwiki-devs] The problem with the rest services for autosuggestion.

Thanks Eduard very much, It is really helpful, today I am trying to use SuggestLuceneService to test the autosuggestion functions, I found a problem. For example, I create a page named "jamesxu", and upload an attachment named "autosuggest1.js", then I input the query "jame" to the search box on the top right of the page, the suggestion list shows up, but the results in the "Document Name" and "Document Content" contains both the wiki page "jamesxu" and its attachment "autosuggest1.js", this behaviour is not excepted in the autosuggestion features of the editor, because when user types "jame“， he really wants to query the wiki page or attachment begin with or contains "jame", the attachment "autosuggest1.js" does not contains "jame", it should not be included in the suggestion results.

On Tue, Jul 19, 2011 at 10:14 PM, Eduard Moraru&lt;enygma2002(a)gmail.com&gt;wrote;wrote: > Hi James, > > I agree with Marius that you should reuse as much as possible what already > exists instead of creating an alternate service that does, in a great > proportions, the same as an existing one but has one extra feature. > > So, as I was browsing trough REST's resources, I noticed an undocumented > "/wikis/{wikiName}/attachments" [1] resource at the wiki level that is able > to search for attachments. As you can see from the method's signature, it > accepts parameters to filter your search by attachment name, page, space, > author, and type. I will fix the REST API documentation and include it. > > This resource should do the trick for what you need, used in conjunction > with the search resource that should handle documents. > > The advantage of this is that you can get json, as you did for the search > resource. > The disadvantage of the whole REST API, for your needs, might be that it is > limited at wiki level and can not perform a multi-wiki search in one query > (wihout you having to do a search for each wiki). > > On the other side, the Lucene search does not have this problem because it > indexes all the wikis and can perform searches on all wikis in one query > and > it does it much faster than REST (which uses database queries). Also, > lucene > is used in the search suggest (the one at the top-right corner of the > screen) and in the main XWiki search as well, so it would be much better if > the results were consistent. Besides this, if the lucene system is improved > over time, your results will also be improved as a result. > > So my suggestion is that you modify XWiki.SuggestLuceneService and make it > accept a "media" parameter (or something similar) that should accept at > least 2 values: "xml"(default) and "json". Based on this value, you can > wrap > the results of the lucene search into a basic json structure that you can > easily use in your suggest box. You can check [2][3] and [4] for references > of how to use Lucene search in XWiki. > Once you are done with it, you can even do a pull request so that this > feature gets integrated into XWiki. > > The best and cleanest solution would be that the REST search resource used > internally lucene instead of a custom database query and that there would > be > a single search back-end (preferably configurable in administration). > Anyway, it's not your job to fix XWiki :) so making > XWiki.SuggestLuceneService return json too is the best way to go right now, > IMO. > > Thanks, > Eduard > > ----------------- > References: > [1] > > https://github.com/xwiki/xwiki-platform/blob/master/xwiki-platform-core/xwi… > [2] http://extensions.xwiki.org/xwiki/bin/view/Extension/Lucene+Plugin > [3] > > https://github.com/xwiki/xwiki-platform/blob/master/xwiki-platform-core/xwi… > [4] > > https://github.com/xwiki/xwiki-platform/blob/master/xwiki-platform-core/xwi… > > > On Tue, Jul 19, 2011 at 8:36 AM, 许凌志(Jamesxu)&lt;lingzhixu326(a)gmail.com >> wrote: > >> Hi, these days I need to implement the rest services for getting > suggestion >> results for link autosuggestion. In my design, I think the suggestion >> results should be filtered and ranked by the following conditions. >> (for example user types "[[mytest" in page "xwiki:main.newpage") >> First [[ is triggered, when user keep typing, the page and attachment >> suggestion results should be filtered and ranked by the following rules: >> 1. Prefix matched (only for page name and attachment name) >> - The pages which are in the same wiki and space of the document > current >> edited.( Prior A) >> - The pages which are in the same wiki but different space of the >> document current edited;(Prior B) >> - The pages which are in different wiki and different space of the >> document current edited; (Prior C); >> 2. Partial matched (only for page name and attachment name) >> - The pages which are in the same wiki and space of the document > current >> edited.( Prior C) >> - The pages which are in the same wiki but different space of the >> document current edited;(Prior D) >> - The pages which are in different wiki and different space of the >> document current edited; (Prior E) >> 3. If no page and attachment matches the above two rules, the suggestion >> box will be disappeared.(eclipse way) >> >> However, sometimes user might insert the space name too, for example, > user >> will type "[[Main", following the rule 1 and rule 2, the pages begins > with >> "Main" will be first retrieved as the suggestion results untill user > types >> "." after "Main", the suggestion result will be retreved from the pages >> under the space "Main" only. Filters still obey the above three rules. >> And also when user types "attach:", the suggestion result will be > retrieved >> the attachments only following the above three rules. >> And if the link is under the attachment context, when "@" is typed, the >> attachments only will be retrieved following the above three rules. >> >> In order to do this, I investigated the rest services already existed( >> http://platform.xwiki.org/xwiki/bin/view/Features/XWikiRESTfulAPI), but > I >> found none is perfect suitable for my needs. So I talk with Marius, he >> suggested me to use the existed services which are closed to my needs >> first, >> and then write the perfect one later. >> >> However, I only found the rest service:/wikis/{wiki}/search is the most >> closed one for the pages suggestion to my needs, there is no attachment >> search rest service for attachment suggestion, Marius adviced me to use " >> >> > http://localhost:8080/xwiki/bin/get/XWiki/SuggestLuceneService?outputSyntax… > < > http://localhost:8080/xwiki/bin/get/XWiki/SuggestLuceneService?outputSyntax… >> >> " >> instead, but I found the search result is in xml format(not json), and > also >> the information of the results got from SuggestLuceneService is limit. >> >> I have read the document of how to write custom rest service, but the >> information is limit, any one can guide me to run an helloworld? >> >> >> >> -- >> Best wishes, >> >> 许凌志(Jame Xu) >> >> MOE KLINNS Lab and SKLMS Lab, Xi'an Jiaotong University >> >> Department of Computer Science and Technology, Xi’an Jiaotong University