Re: [xwiki-dev] [JIRA] Missing "fix for" fields... - xwiki-devs@xwiki.org

22 Jan 2007

On Nov 15, 2006, at 12:48 PM, Ludovic Dubost wrote:
...

 It's not sure that we will find exactly in which version they have  
 been
 fixed.
 If we are working on the head, is the policy to mark it fix for the
 upcoming release ? The policy is to fill the "fix for" either:
* When you're planning to fix an issue for a given release. If it  
happens that it's not fixed for that release then the fix for must be  
updated at the time of the release
* When you're closing an issue

In any case there should never be any issue closed without a "fix  
for" filled.
...
  in this case what happens if the upcoming release
 never comes out or does not have the version number that we thought I'm not
sure what you mean. Imagine that we define a version named  
1.1 planned for a given date. Now imagine that we decide not to  
release this version and instead to name it 1.0.9. Then in JIRA we'll  
rename 1.1 in 1.0.9 and all issues will then have a fix for for 1.0.9.

I'm probably not understanding something here :-)

Thanks
-Vincent

...
  Maybe we need to define our versioning policy

 Ludovic

 Vincent Massol a écrit :
  Hi developers,

 I've noticed that there are 43 issues which are resolved or    closed and
which
  do not have a "fix for" value. This
means that these issues are    not going to
  be associated with a XWiki version which also
means that they are
 unaccounted for and that users cannot know in which version they    have been
  fixed.

 I think it would be good if everyone had a look and added a "fix    for"
value
  for the issues they have fixed.

 WDYT?

 Note: With the default jira workflow it's not possible to edit an    issue
that
  has been closed so you'll have to reopen it
and close it again.    If you want
  I can also modify the workflow to allow editing
an issue that's    been closed.
  Let me know.

 Thanks
 -Vincent 