Hi Tharindu, I have done a first pass on the code review and I have a few comments: 1) You seem to have use Cloudgarden's Jigloo and unfortunately the license isn't good enough for us so we cannot use it... Here's what it says in the generated file: /** * This code was edited or generated using CloudGarden's Jigloo SWT/Swing GUI Builder, which is free * for non-commercial use. If Jigloo is being used commercially (ie, by a corporation, company or * business for any purpose whatever) then you should purchase a license for each developer using * Jigloo. Please visit www.cloudgarden.com for details. Use of Jigloo implies acceptance of these * licensing terms. A COMMERCIAL LICENSE HAS NOT BEEN PURCHASED FOR THIS MACHINE, SO JIGLOO OR THIS * CODE CANNOT BE USED LEGALLY FOR ANY CORPORATE OR COMMERCIAL PURPOSE. */ We cannot use Jigloo because we want commercial companies using XWiki under the LGPL license. Thus we cannot commit this code. Could you find some alternative? The UI doesn't seem too complex so I should be easy to do it by hand I think.

improved, especially for Classes. This is the most important Javadoc and should answer the question "what is the class for?". Also please see: http://www.xwiki.org/xwiki/bin/view/Community/CodeStyle#HDonotuse27public27… http://www.xwiki.org/xwiki/bin/view/Community/CodeStyle#HDonotduplicatemeth… Parameters and return value shouldn't start with "-" in javadoc. See the Sun's Javadoc coding conventions.

Instead we'll add Asiri and yourself to the Hall of Fame + in the SVN commits. The rest sounds good. We need to add maven build of course. I'll start looking into that after we fix the points above. Also, I haven't coded plugins in Eclipse for a very very long time so I have no idea if what you've done is the right way of doing it so I'll assume it is :-) Thanks again and keep up the good work! -Vincent On Jul 15, 2007, at 10:04 AM, tharindu jayasuriya wrote: Hi all, This is about r.1.0.m1 version of xeclipse (XWiki-Eclipse-Plugin). We have completed following tasks in this release, 1. Cleaned up source code ( need to be confirmed by Vincent ) 2. Implemented adding/deleting pages. - Adding pages does not seem to work correctly due to some errors in XML-RPC implementation of XWiki, need to look into this. - Removing pages does not work at all because the corresponding XML-RPC is not implemented in XWiki. 3. Implemented adding/deleting spaces. - Adding spaces work fine. - Deleting spaces does not work (RPC not implemented in XWiki) As it's obvious by now, we need to peek into XWiki internals to get these issues fixed. But since we have a scheduled release today (and these issues showed up all of a sudden), we thought of finishing the work from the plugin's end and uploading the relevant work. Anyway, those issues need to be fixed asap. We have tested the work on a stand alone (HSQLDB) Xwiki installation, it would be really nice if someone can test the plugin on a real server and confirm the results :) Vincent, I couldn't find an appropriate place to upload the files in XWIKI JIRA, so i thought of attaching relevant files into this email. I'm really sorry for any inconveniences. Hope to hear from you very soon. Thanks a lot! - Tharindu & Asiri <xeclipse.r.1.0.m1.eclipse.project.zip> <xeclipse_1.0.0.jar> -- You receive this message as a subscriber of the xwiki-dev(a)objectweb.orgmailing list. To unsubscribe: mailto:xwiki-dev-unsubscribe@objectweb.org &lt;xwiki-dev-unsubscribe(a)objectweb.org&gt; For general help: mailto:sympa@objectweb.org?subject=help<sympa@objectweb.org?subject=help> ObjectWeb mailing lists service home page: http://www.objectweb.org/wws -- You receive this message as a subscriber of the xwiki-dev(a)objectweb.orgmailing list. To unsubscribe: mailto:xwiki-dev-unsubscribe@objectweb.org For general help: mailto: sympa(a)objectweb.org?subject=help ObjectWeb mailing lists service home page: http://www.objectweb.org/wws

On 7/16/07, Vincent Massol < vincent(a)massol.net&gt; wrote: I was thinking whether it would be legal (and ethical) if we look at jigloo generated code and write our own code (without copy and paste...) ?. I really have this doubt over all open source software, what if some commercial vendor looks at XWiki code, rewrite the code, do some feature additions, remove all the licensing info and claim that it's a new product (which they own) ?

3) Please add copyright to all classes and don't use the @author tag. > Instead we'll add Asiri and yourself to the Hall of Fame + in the SVN > commits. > > The rest sounds good. We need to add maven build of course. I'll start > looking into that after we fix the points above. > > Also, I haven't coded plugins in Eclipse for a very very long time so > I have no idea if what you've done is the right way of doing it so I'll > assume it is :-) > > Thanks again and keep up the good work! > -Vincent > > On Jul 15, 2007, at 10:04 AM, tharindu jayasuriya wrote: > > Hi all, > > This is about r.1.0.m1 version of xeclipse (XWiki-Eclipse-Plugin). > > We have completed following tasks in this release, > > 1. Cleaned up source code ( need to be confirmed by Vincent ) > > 2. Implemented adding/deleting pages. > > - Adding pages does not seem to work correctly due to some errors > in XML-RPC implementation of XWiki, need to look into this. > - Removing pages does not work at all because the corresponding > XML-RPC is not implemented in XWiki. > > 3. Implemented adding/deleting spaces. > > - Adding spaces work fine. > - Deleting spaces does not work (RPC not implemented in XWiki) > > As it's obvious by now, we need to peek into XWiki internals to get > these issues fixed. But since we have a scheduled release today (and these > issues showed up all of a sudden), we thought of finishing the work from the > plugin's end and uploading the relevant work. Anyway, those issues need to > be fixed asap. > > We have tested the work on a stand alone (HSQLDB) Xwiki installation, > it would be really nice if someone can test the plugin on a real server and > confirm the results :) > > Vincent, I couldn't find an appropriate place to upload the files in > XWIKI JIRA, so i thought of attaching relevant files into this email. I'm > really sorry for any inconveniences. > > Hope to hear from you very soon. > > Thanks a lot! > > - Tharindu & Asiri > > <xeclipse.r.1.0.m1.eclipse.project.zip> > <xeclipse_1.0.0.jar> > >

On 7/16/07, Vincent Massol < vincent(a)massol.net&gt; wrote: I was thinking whether it would be legal (and ethical) if we look at jigloo generated code and write our own code (without copy and paste...) ?. I really have this doubt over all open source software, what if some commercial vendor looks at XWiki code, rewrite the code, do some feature additions, remove all the licensing info and claim that it's a new product (which they own) ?

Hi All, Attached are the latest sources and binaries of XEclipse m1. Issues Fixed, 1. All Jigloo dependencies removed. 2. Code documentation improved according to instructions from Vincent. 3. Back-End XML RPC's patched to suite XEclipse (Asiri) http://jira.xwiki.org/jira/browse/XWIKI-1520 http://jira.xwiki.org/jira/browse/XWIKI-1521 http://jira.xwiki.org/jira/browse/XWIKI-1524 Let's hope this would finalize XEclipse m1 ... :) Hoping to hear from you soon... Thanks. - Tharindu & Asiri On 7/16/07, Vincent Massol &lt;vincent(a)massol.net > wrote: Hi Tharindu, I have done a first pass on the code review and I have a few comments: 1) You seem to have use Cloudgarden's Jigloo and unfortunately the license isn't good enough for us so we cannot use it... Here's what it says in the generated file: /** * This code was edited or generated using CloudGarden's Jigloo SWT/ Swing GUI Builder, which is free * for non-commercial use. If Jigloo is being used commercially (ie, by a corporation, company or * business for any purpose whatever) then you should purchase a license for each developer using * Jigloo. Please visit www.cloudgarden.com for details. Use of Jigloo implies acceptance of these * licensing terms. A COMMERCIAL LICENSE HAS NOT BEEN PURCHASED FOR THIS MACHINE, SO JIGLOO OR THIS * CODE CANNOT BE USED LEGALLY FOR ANY CORPORATE OR COMMERCIAL PURPOSE. */ We cannot use Jigloo because we want commercial companies using XWiki under the LGPL license. Thus we cannot commit this code. Could you find some alternative? The UI doesn't seem too complex so I should be easy to do it by hand I think. 2) Thanks for your javadoc. It's nice and helps a lot. However it can be improved, especially for Classes. This is the most important Javadoc and should answer the question "what is the class for?". Also please see: http://www.xwiki.org/xwiki/bin/view/Community/ CodeStyle#HDonotuse27public27ininterfaces http://www.xwiki.org/xwiki/bin/view/Community/ CodeStyle#HDonotduplicatemethodcommentswithparameterscomments Parameters and return value shouldn't start with "-" in javadoc. See the Sun's Javadoc coding conventions. 3) Please add copyright to all classes and don't use the @author tag. Instead we'll add Asiri and yourself to the Hall of Fame + in the SVN commits. The rest sounds good. We need to add maven build of course. I'll start looking into that after we fix the points above. Also, I haven't coded plugins in Eclipse for a very very long time so I have no idea if what you've done is the right way of doing it so I'll assume it is :-) Thanks again and keep up the good work! -Vincent On Jul 15, 2007, at 10:04 AM, tharindu jayasuriya wrote: > Hi all, > > This is about r.1.0.m1 version of xeclipse (XWiki-Eclipse-Plugin). > > We have completed following tasks in this release, > > 1. Cleaned up source code ( need to be confirmed by Vincent ) > > 2. Implemented adding/deleting pages. > > - Adding pages does not seem to work correctly due to some > errors in XML-RPC implementation of XWiki, need to look into this. > - Removing pages does not work at all because the > corresponding XML-RPC is not implemented in XWiki. > > 3. Implemented adding/deleting spaces. > > - Adding spaces work fine. > - Deleting spaces does not work (RPC not implemented in XWiki) > > As it's obvious by now, we need to peek into XWiki internals to > get these issues fixed. But since we have a scheduled release > today (and these issues showed up all of a sudden), we thought of > finishing the work from the plugin's end and uploading the > relevant work. Anyway, those issues need to be fixed asap. > > We have tested the work on a stand alone (HSQLDB) Xwiki > installation, it would be really nice if someone can test the > plugin on a real server and confirm the results :) > > Vincent, I couldn't find an appropriate place to upload the files > in XWIKI JIRA, so i thought of attaching relevant files into this > email. I'm really sorry for any inconveniences. > > Hope to hear from you very soon. > > Thanks a lot! > > - Tharindu & Asiri >